David Hestenes is himself a physicists. He did a lot to bring Clifford algebras into the main public attention (mainly applying it to the study of space-time). He used the term "geometric algebra" because it looks like this was the term used by Clifford in his work.
There is nothing wrong with teaching the cross product, some people (me included) just think that teaching about exterior (and geometric) products would be more productive.
Introducing the concepts in the context of a euclidean metric seems unmotivated?
I think you're generally right that GA is a rebranding of concepts we already knew about, however representing them in a uniform manner seems like a useful thing to do. The at t=4083 in the video they show some interesting examples of projections, rotations, and other geometric operations that can be done quite simply https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tX4H_ctggYo&t=4083
One example is why you multiply normals by the world_inverse_tranpose. Apparently the reason is because normals are actually bivectors, not directional vectors as they are usually explained.
another is that at least in code, they apparently solve lots of issues that other methods don't
See: https://marctenbosch.com/quaternions/
I know linear algebra but I have no idea what the heck this means. Is this a gaming thing?
e: I'm restating the question in a form I understand, not asking it.
For example, let T be a reflection about the plane spanned by e1 and e2. Then T(e1^e2)=e1^e2, but T(e1 x e2) = -e1 x e2, where "x" denotes the cross product.
The "inverse transpose" is a symbolic manipulation to derive a transformation matrix that inverts the scale, but not the rotation, though it's actually a bit overzealous, you can actually just use the cofactor matrix. https://github.com/graphitemaster/normals_revisited
That's when they start telling you, that you're supposed to be an elite mathematician, well versed in the higher forms of sophistry, and if that were the case you wouldn't need to understand bivector and wedge product and what not at an intuitive level.
I'm sold.
Especially when you teach applied math for nonmathematicians. For example teaching analysis using infinitesimals for engineers might be pedagogically better (for the level of understanding required).
I'm not expert in history of mathematics, but If I remember correctly there was lots of fighting over represetations related to hypercomplex systems, vectors and matrices in the 1800-century. Quaternion Society wanted to do it one way. https://www.nature.com/articles/052545a0
Anyway, that's why I use it. I'm 43.
1. What's the difference between Geometric Algebra and exterior algebras? Clifford algebras?
This is a hand-wavy explanation, but the GA community has specific GAs give a geometric meaning to objects and operations of some Clifford algebra. For example, there's a 5D algebra (Conformal Geoemtric Algebra?), which is really a 2^5=32D algebra, where elements of the algebra can represent points, point pairs, circles, planes, etc. On the level of Clifford algebra, any of these objects is a point in a 32D space, and operations on points give you other points. That's sort of the mechanics. And then it's the job of GA to give a geometric interpretation of the points and the operations. To draw an analogy to logic, I think of it as syntax vs semantics.
2. Also, what's wrong with cross products?
I just explained how GA is sort of unifying and uniforming. All sorts of disparate geometric objects can be treated uniformly in one representation.
At the same time GA allows you to distinguish between objects that are different. If you give me a vector `A` and a vector `B`, and I return to you `C=A×B`, on the "syntax" level, A, B, and C look the same. If we're thinking in terms of coordinates, they are all triples of real numbers.
But `C` is unlike `A` or `B`. For example, if you wish to operate under a different coordinate system, you might have a transformation matrix M to convert between old and new coordinates. So for example `Anew = M * A`, `Bnew = M * B`, and `Cnew = det(M) * M^{-1}^{T} * C` [2]. What what? The explanationsSome would use is that `A` and `B` are true vectors or polar vectors, and `C` is a pseudovector or axial vector.
In code that I write, I would very much like to have some distinction between vectors that transform like `A` or `B` and vectors that transform like `C`. You can do this with naming conventions, or just making sure you do keep track in some other way that. A GA framework would give you a way to track this difference. In my opinion (and there are many ways to accomplish the same thing) the programming language type of `C` should be distinct from `A`.
I think Hodge duality and the cross product are important, and I honestly don't know what's right to teach kids in high school. The tradition we currently have gets us pretty far. On the other hand, how awkward is it to invoke the notion of C being a "pseudovector" [3]? I think most people never really learn that. The first time I really reckoned with that was when learning computer graphics, because normal vectors transform differently from tangent vectors. Incidentally, if what I wrote doesn't make sense to anyone, learning about these concepts by thinking of normal vectors vs tangent vectors is probably an intuitive motivation. This page should help: https://www.scratchapixel.com/lessons/mathematics-physics-fo...
For anyone who might not know, "an oriented 3-dimensional Euclidean space, an oriented plane can be represented by the exterior product of two basis vectors, and its Hodge dual is the normal vector given by their cross product" [1].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hodge_star_operator
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cross_product#Algebraic_proper...
I wish it had been earlier because I think it is important to have a strong idea of what the objects you are working with are and what properties they have.
Here you go:
A = <1.0, 2.0, 3.0, 4.0>
B = <5.0, 6.0, 7.0, 8.0>
What exactly is A×B supposed to look like there? :)Cross product is awful. The wedge product, on the other hand, is:
# C = <<Ax*By-Ay*Bx,Ax*Bz-Az*Bx,Ax*Bt-At*Bx,
Ay*Bz-Az*By,Ay*Bt-At*By,Az*Bt-At*Bz>>
# C = <<1*6-2*5,1*7-3*5,1*8-4*5,2*7-3*6,2*8-4*6,3*8-4*7>>
# C = <<6-10,7-15,8-20,14-18,16-24,24-28>>
C = <<-4.0,-8.0,-12.0,-4.0,-8.0,-4.0>>
Which works fine for any number of dimensions. (Assuming coordinate-lexicographic order (resonable) and that I didn't screw up the arithmetic (less so).)You would instead need to do CrossProduct(A, B, C) and calculate the determinant of the 4x4 matrix with the last row being the $\mathbb{R}^4$ basis.
You could also create a function by lazy evaluation of CrossProduct(A, B) : $\mathbb{R}^4 \rightarrow \mathbb{R}^4$
Thats also true for R^3: does <1,0,0>x<0,1,0> give <0,0,1>, or <0,0,-1>?
it's completely specified by the order of A and B - there are two possible orders and two possible vectors.