David Graeber Left Us a Parting Gift – His Thoughts on Kropotkin’s “Mutual Aid”
truthout.org
truthout.org
By putting every trait through the "it must help gene selection somehow" is simply wrong and isn't scientific.
Also, why doesn't mutual aid apply to human societies? I haven't seen any evidence why it wouldn't considering the fact that its so pervasive. I literally see it everyday.
In terms of mutual aid not applying to human societies I mean Kropotkin's idea of it as something he thought was a natural instinct of helpfulness. Obviously humans can and should help each other, but this has nothing to do with our instincts. Humans share the genetic programming of other animals, but because of our greater reasoning powers we can go beyond our instincts.