A big part of their hesitation to allow outside service is probably the fact that any given Tesla may have any number of slight adjustments that require slightly different parts or repair tactics, and they don't really want to publicly admit how many different variations of everything there is.
You can see in these pictures that in addition to them using some stock wood trim pieces... those wood trim pieces differ a bit from car to car. One would hope if the materials used between these cars differ, that their system knows this, in case one approach proves to be defective or dangerous, and they need to track down every car that they employed this hack in.
Yeah, I’m gonna stop you right there. I have serious doubts a company that sees no problem with making a quick Home Depot run for some faux wood trim in order to get a car out the door is meticulously documenting all their little hacks.
Cars aren't software; to do that with cars without large identical (by intent) production runs (to control for process noise) it would seem like you would need extraordinary process control (and every indication I've seen has that Tesla varies from incumbents in the opposite direction), otherwise you are chasing process noise.
I have no idea the risk/reward equation here. I am guessing most people voting and commenting here have no idea the risk/reward equation. My comment was only pointing at that lots of people are going to have an opinion on this that is mostly dictated by their previous assumptions about Tesla as a company.
> I have no preconceived notions, but this is clearly A. I honestly can't understand how anyone can see this as anything but A.
Congrats, you've failed the test. Earlier today I didn't realize it was possible to fail a Rorschach test
Reminds me of that time the psychologist kept showing me pictures of my parents fighting. She insisted that they were just blots of ink. I'm not sure what she was playing at.
Maybe it's A, maybe it's B. Oh, you only see an A? Fail.
Do you trust that some engineers at Tesla needed a solution to a problem, modelled it out, did some materials testing and discovered that this plastic panelling was the right material for this job?
It does look bad because it's obviously not produced by Tesla, but so many parts are outsourced already in car manufacturing, this could be a solid engineering choice that's getting some bad publicity.
Of course, it could also be because some intern was tasked at solving a design problem and slapped this together overnight, and no one ever checked his work, and it went into production.
Alllll about trust.
That would be more credible if it was the same in all cars; it is not (see the source).
IMHO, I doubt they spent even that much time on it, and that is what worries me.