Actually, no. Sometimes it is fatal, and sometimes it's not.
If the file being open is expected to be part of the distribution and your app can't start without it, it's fatal.
If it's a file picked by the user, it's most likely recoverable.
The main problem is that every single one of these exceptions should be able to be either runtime or checked, and that choice should be made by the application.
Open question: should this decision be made at the call site or the use site?