I recently switched from ivy to selectrum as well. I miss some stuff like ivy-rich, but I found integration with prescient.el[1] more important than an eye candy (where ivy-prescient breaks every few version). I still haven't got a chance to rewrite ivy-ag with selectrum^note1, but it has been working great so far.
My only issue with selectrum was, back when I'm using ivy, I rebind forward direction keys (<right>/C-l/C-f) to `ivy-partial-or-done` which either complete the input with the selection or visit a file depending on the context. Selectrum doesn't have equivalent implementation, but it's easy enough to implement. Reposting in here in case anybody needs it:
(defun gemacs--selectrum-insert-or-submit-current-candidate ()
"Insert current candidate or forward to `selectrum-select-current-candidate'
if input text hasn't changed since last completion."
(interactive)
(let ((prev-input (selectrum-get-current-input)))
(when (> (length (selectrum-get-current-candidates)) 0)
(selectrum-insert-current-candidate))
(when (string= prev-input (selectrum-get-current-input))
(selectrum-select-current-candidate))))
[1]: https://github.com/raxod502/prescient.el^note1: I don't use rg due to dependency on PCRE2 which doesn't play nice on my OpenBSD machine.