I always wonder, when I read this and similar claims, how on earth the tone of 100% certainty is justified. It seems pure bluff.
Sounds probable, but I can see many possible reasons not to bother. Not to mention it is speculating about technology so far ahead of our own that it seems silly. 50's predictions of rocket belts and nuclear powered cars come to mind.
These are different kind of predictions. Rocket belts could work, but they don't make economic sense and there's a strong safety argument against it. It's the same reason we don't have flying cars either.
Nuclear-powered cars could have worked; the failure wasn't predicting technology or its feasibility, but that nobody figured out humanity will collectively go insane and irrationally refuse to develop use of nuclear energy.
Dyson spheres are a pretty obvious thing to do - every star is a free, self-maintaining fusion generator that just wastes almost 100% of its output. So the argument is really that when a civilization's need for energy gets larger than what can be supplied by burning whatever stuff they have on their planet, the next obvious step is their star. Barring some magic tech breakthroughs like pulling energy from "subspace" or whatever, you have a rather solid argument that's essentially: "as long as life is not limited from growing, it will eventually start blotting out the sun it orbits".
I don't disagree that the core idea of harnessing the suns energy seems likely. As the parent poster said, it's just the absolute confidence that people seem to have on the subject that's a bit curious.
Maybe breakthroughs in energy generation will make it not worth the effort? Maybe becoming interstellar makes it obsolete since the energy requirements for a given civilization are spread thinner? Maybe there are other ways to harness the solar energy that would not show the same signs as we predict? Maybe civilizations trend to energy efficiency instead of just increased usage?
Maybe not.
https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Basic_AI_drives
The above link is about AI, but it could apply to any alien species just as well.
Any organism living in a thermodynamic universe and subject to competition and evolutionary pressures will develop instinctual drives that align with resource acquisition, replication, and survival. As the above link details this surprisingly holds true even when you remove evolution and consider designed minds.
Even if a hypothetical civilization didn’t care about resource acquisition, replication and survival, they’d be out-competed by one which did. So where is that civilization’s ever expanding sphere of Dyson clouds?
Even with the most advanced technology we can imagine, you can't expect to be able to detect a neighboring civilization, cross the gap between stars with an invading fleet, and arrive with enough power to overwhelm defenses every single time. Local development of solar system resources is inherently an exponential process, whereas mustering of interstellar resources is quadratic. A potential dark forest / wolf entity (I much prefer Alastair Reynolds over Liu Cixin) would have to arrive right within the (cosmically brief) window of opportunity in which a developing civilization announces its presence but before it achieves Type II status on the Kardashev scale. Statistically, someone will eventually be lucky enough to avoid the wolves long enough to get that far, and then they'd have the capability to defend themselves from any plausible enemy.
Where are the Dyson spheres of those civilizations?
It should be emphasized that the existence of convergent instrumental reasons, even if they apply to and are recognized by a particular agent, does not imply that the agent’s behavior is easily predictable. An agent might well think of ways of pursuing the relevant instrumental values that do not readily occur to us. This is especially true for a superintelligence, which could devise extremely clever but counterintuitive plans to realize its goals, possibly even exploiting as-yet undiscovered physical phenomena. What is predictable is that the convergent instrumental values would be pursued and used to realize the agent’s final goals, not the specific actions that the agent would take to achieve this.
Or energy is not such a big deal anymore once you've reached a certain stage of technological advancement, so it's not the right criteria.
Most scientists believe that even if the star is encased in Dyson sphere that there would be excess infrared emissions as the sphere would need to vent heat. It would be hotter than surrounding space and thus visible.
They are thus trying to detect such stars with higher mass and IR excess than expected, but so far there are not many candidates.
You know that. But it bears mention, for others following along, that rampant artificial intelligence or similar does not count as a great filter candidate, because it would be just as visible as the life it's replacing.
That doesn't leave a lot of fast-acting filters that could still be in our future, to be honest. Nuclear war? Sure, but we've avoided it too long for that to be a good one either.
75 years is an infinitessimal blip of time in cosmic terms.