To use the meme, an AI won't be smarter than us; it'll be faster at being stupid.
Computers beating humans at chess is a great example of not being smarter, but being stupid faster. Both humans and computers approach PSPACE-complete problems like chess by approximating their searches and looking at trees of possible moves. We have no special insights into how to consider or evaluate moves; we have psychological profiles on which moves might be connected during practical play but no reason to require people to make such moves, and those profiles are largely limited to "openings", classifying the relatively few initial trees.
How do computers beat humans in chess? They do exactly what we do, but faster. This isn't smart, but fast stupid.