Some HN readers apparently don't like to hear this but I don't see any other way.
As for how we can reduce regulatory capture, I don't believe there is any good solution other than constant vigilance.
Some HN readers apparently don't like to hear this but I don't see any other way.
As for how we can reduce regulatory capture, I don't believe there is any good solution other than constant vigilance.
- Better whistleblower protections
- Personal liability for making false or misleading statements to a regulatory agent
- Corporate death penalty. No more "too big to fail" nonsense. If there were actual competition among aviation manufacturers, the government could just dissolve the company and auction off the product lines to competitors.
Safeguarding against capture from the regulatory side is more difficult. But I guess term limits for decision-making positions could help, or having a good process for identifying and declaring conflicts of interest?
There are a number of industries and companies that will exist as long as the current USG does, at least for our lifetimes, due to decisions that were made long ago.
Examples include Lockheed, Boeing, and Microsoft.
Any solution to the problem needs to accept and address the levels of deep integration between these companies and the state.
It'd require a lot more ass-covering to pretend that the company isn't just an arm of the government, entitled to a neverending stream of practically unlimited tax dollars.
Look at the whole kerfuffle that Amazon is making over JEDI being given to Microsoft. Under the current system, that's probably better avoided.
I am not sure what capping executive salaries would achieve. You'd still get the same kind of people at the top anyway - even if the top salaries were identical to that of a janitor, the fact that you have power over others is its own motivator for many people out there. Proof in point: politicians don't make outrageous amounts of money (compared to CEOs), but they are addicted to power and control just as well.
There are some CEOs in the Fortune 500 with 750k base, but bonus and stock exceed that by multiples.
"The median total compensation for Fortune 500 CEOs who had been in their role for at least two years was $11.5 million"
https://www.marketwatch.com/story/fortune-500-ceos-are-paid-...
I think a fifty times multiplier is already too high though so I don't know if I can agree to pushing that up any further. The goal is specifically to change things for the better, to NOT maintain the status quo.
You might have seen this recent news article. I won't summarise, as I don't think I can do better than the URL:
https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2020/08/ea-shareholders-say-n...
That doesn't make much sense though. The size of rewards might incentivize how hard someone works for them and to what extremes, but the objective they're working towards depends on what the reward is, well, rewarding, which is a separate thing. It's perfectly possible to imagine a system where executive compensation was based purely around safety for example, say "$5 million for no flaw-derived fatalities during tenure of 10 years and another $5 million for no flaw-derived fatalities for anything manufactured during tenure for 10 years after retirement", or whatever exact numbers/details you wish. Of course, even that could be "outsized" in that too high+unbalanced a level might encourage the extreme of too little innovation. But merely saying "executives shouldn't get paid more than [number pulled out a random because who knows]" doesn't seem like a directed policy that'd help. And in fact is quite contrary to other comments calling for more personal responsibility and the like.
like holding family members hostage? Or perhaps violent mutilation on failure? The financial route has been ramped up as far as can be imagined - $100m's are paid to CEOs to fail, and to wreak the economy, society and the planet at the same time.