Also, why should "just use Vulkan and be done with"? Vulkan is just another standard, being open doesn't mean it's better, or more suited to their needs (they have a platform to consider, they're not about cross-platformness).
Also, why should "just use Vulkan and be done with"? Vulkan is just another standard, being open doesn't mean it's better, or more suited to their needs (they have a platform to consider, they're not about cross-platformness).
That a company wants its own API to move freely and faster is often described as evil when it is merely sensible for them. It used to cause lock-in, but nowadays there are enough tech stack that isolate you from the underlying API to make it irrelevant.
Do note that until, oh let's arbitrarily say 10 years ago, DirectX was ahead feature-wise to OpenGL and OpenGL was moving at turtle pace.
If features are what they need, Khronos accepts any company as a member.
Isn't the people kidding themselves that ones that consider it a "strange" or "troubling" reason that a company has a product and wants to sell that product?
The whole point of having an OS is that it's different than another OS. If all OSes just used the same APIs (filesystems, graphics, sound, etc) we'd just have one OS.
That's something shared by unices and Linux follows course, but it's not the idea behind (or the ideal of) other OSes.
And I don't want a world where there's a single set of APIs for all OSes, and all OSes give the same core functionality in the same implementation (e.g. Vulcan + OpenAL + POSIX + ...).
Having all OSes be that (e.g. all use Vulcan), would be the same situation as everybody using DirectX (innovation wise), the only exception being that Vulcan is free/open.
But I don't want openess about all, I also want variety and different innovations, and platforms offering unique stuff...
The moat APIs created by OS vendors are mostly in their interest. Does anyone but Apple want an API like Metal? Developers don't. User see no benefit. Only Apple benefits.
I'm not saying there should be only one globally used API for every task, but praising APIs that exist only to be moats to increase corporate profits is another.
About innovation, everyone can join Khronos (for free) and contribute to their API of choice. You can add whichever extension you want to these APIs, and if they are found useful they are included in the main standard.
Write once, add code paths and debug everywhere.
It was not that long ago that some important websites, such as bank or government, required IE.
Microsoft embraced the browser market, extended it (activex along with some genuine innovatives such as ajax) and then extinguished it by letting IE languish.
The technological progress recovered thanks to efforts by Mozilla, KDE, Google and Apple, but who knows how our world might have looked like if Microsoft had not been successful in EEE'ing the web.
Agreed.
> KDE.
Agreed.
> Google and Apple.
Out of the frying pan and into the fire :-)