Let’s say it takes 5 years to recoup that initial investment to procure materials and manufacture masks at current pricing. Most experts agree the pandemic will have run its course within a year or two. So common sense says getting into the mask business where it will take 5 years to recoup your losses is a bad bet.
But if pricing was allowed to follow demand, there is more incentive for aspiring mask manufacturers to take those risks. Maybe the cost to ramp up production can be covered in a couple of years or maybe even a couple of months. That mitigates risk and given opportunity like that, existing mask manufacturers will be better incentivized to scale their production more rapidly. And then more masks get produced quickly, scarcity decreases, and pricing eventually finds equilibrium again.
But because we don’t allow “gouging” (whether for legal or social reasons), the mask shortage will continue until existing manufacturers can produce enough to meet demand. And some people that need PPE won’t have it easily available until then, but we will feel awfully good about making sure nobody got gouged. After all, nobody gets gouged if there is nothing to buy.
Yes, obviously - what did you think deficit spending was? But the point is the cost of fiscal expenditure is lower than it has been in the past, and it seems like we have a really useful thing we could be spending it on.
To me, it seems like normal "propensity to consume + ability to pay" style distribution of masks won't help that much in a pandemic that disproportionately spreads among the poor and where the more people wearing the mask, the better.
As Friedman famously asked - who are the angels that are supposed to make these wise, unbiased decisions on our behalf?
Ah yes, as opposed to the rational private market of large capital investments to create new industries, which is apolitical and has no cronyism /s (never mind no price incentive to massively invest in large-scale manufacturing for a temporary pandemic)
I do not think it even remotely holds in the illiquid limit of massive-scale private capital investment markets. I would rather that power be wielded by actors exercising public power shaped by institutional constraints than by private actors who can wield it in an arbitrary manner, particularly in the context of a pandemic where there is a huge societal difference between 10 $10 masks and 100 $1 ones.
Governments that are democratically accountable to the people are far more likely to create outcomes that support collective social needs than are business owners who are accountable to no one.
The fact that the United States does such a poor job of this is an indictment of poor governance, and lack of democratic accountability, than a weakness of the principle of government in general. Other countries do far better at this--note the universal availability of rated masks in places like Korea and Japan from day one of the pandemic--and there is a reason the US is ranked 22nd, and falling, for public corruption.[0]