That seemed to be a bug and is fixed now. After two parties enter a channel it should give you a "room is full" response.
> Magic Wormhole works a bit differently. IIRC it dynamically requests a channel from the server which is prepended to the passphrase as a number. This seems a bit more resilient to me, as the birthday problem suggests it's quite likely two people will end up with the same channel just by bad luck with Croc....There are only ~900 different three letter word beginnings in the wordlist, so you'd only need to claim that many channels on the server to make it unusable for anyone who lets Croc pick passwords, and occasional collisions between users are certain. Lol that should probably be fixed.
I think wormhole uses only 99 channels [1] so it is also susceptible to a DOS attack. But generally, collisions in channels can occur but are probably pretty rare because I don't have enough people using croc simultaneously to collide. Importantly - colliding channels doesn't undermine security because you have to have the whole passphrase to successfully perform PAKE. But, when you say it should probably be fixed, you refer to mitigating a DOS attack?