Like I said it requires trading experience, you can't gain trading experience without trading. He's young, he can afford to make mistakes in the market and learn from them. Accumulating stock like SPY and AAPL is good if you're older and want to play it relatively safe, you won't make much but won't lose much either. Depends on you risk tolerance, but I wouldn't steer OP away from it, when is he suppose to learn options trading and hedging, when he's 50?