ISPs are regulated, and operate in the country I live in. They know my real identity, bill me regularly, and have (IMHO) a pretty strong incentive to violate my privacy -- either for commercial purposes, or by law. VPNs are not necessarily in my jurisdiction, exist in a highly competitive space, and live or die by their reputation for privacy. You can buy, e.g., time on Mullvad by mailing cash in the post -- or via a whole string of privacy-preserving altcoins. It doesn't get more anonymous than that.