Edward Snowden agrees to give up more than $5M from book and speeches
edition.cnn.com
edition.cnn.com
Quote from Edward Snowden:
“CNN badly misreported this.
A) This is not a settlement; I didn't agree to it.
B) The judgement from this censorship case is not enforceable while I am in exile, but I've never had that much money anyway.
Better headline: "US could gain up to $5m by pardoning Edward Snowden."”
Providing financial or material support to adversarial foreign actors, agents, parties deemed to be national security threats (under sanctions or DOJ/State/Treasury/et. al. special designation) or fugitives from justice violates a number of federal laws.
As for matters of national security, enforcement of US interests abroad can and often times are addressed with the help of the US military, various regional partners, and intelligence agencies.
[1] And even that is a little weak. The programs he leaked were legal. They were funded by Congress. Run by the executive branch and overseen by the Judicial branch and Congressional committees.
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Snowden#Potential_impac...
[3] From [2] "On June 14, 2015, UK's Sunday Times reported that Russian and Chinese intelligence services had decrypted more than 1 million classified files in the Snowden cache, forcing the UK's MI6 intelligence agency to move agents out of live operations in hostile countries. Sir David Omand, a former director of the UK's GCHQ intelligence gathering agency, described it as a huge strategic setback that was harming Britain, America, and their NATO allies. The Sunday Times said it was not clear whether Russia and China stole Snowden's data or whether Snowden voluntarily handed it over to remain at liberty in Hong Kong and Moscow."
I didn't make any value judgment on this. I'm not even that interested in this. I even qualified my statement on Snowden by saying that you can make a case that the disclosure of the collection programs had public interest and journalist value. If that's all Snowden did, then yes, you can also make the argument that he performed a heroic action (I wouldn't agree, but you can make that argument). But that's not what he did and people want to ignore the uncomfortable part. The man stole hundreds of thousands of intelligence documents that had no public interest value and (willingly or unwillingly) handed it to China and Russia.
Before him, you would be called a tin-hatter for implying that governments spy on everyone.
You are doing exactly the same bad PR laundering of his sins that US is currently doing to Assange.
This is some black-and-white logic I would expect from a 20-year-old.
I see this forum contains a lot of people stealing sensitive government information every day to know exactly why people do what they did in Snowden’s situation.
To be clear. This is not an objective statement. It's a subjective interpretation. The reality is that the People have decided that it is in their interest to maintain a military and an intelligence service overseen by their representatives. We live in a complicated world, and even if the program itself is bad (and it was scuttled I believe), it may have resulted from the right intention of trying to protect people's lives from terrorist attacks.
>Their crimes directly attack the values of a Free society
I don't know what you mean by 'crimes'. That's another subjective interpretation. There were no crimes. It was a legal program overseen by all three branches of government. Maybe it was a bad program and it needed a whistleblower, but again, very few people have issues with Snowden disclosing that. But he didn't have to steal the hundreds of thousands of other documents that had no public interest (that he never released publicly anyway), didn't have to take those documents to a foreign adversary. Worse there is evidence that he gave those documents (willingly or willingly) to the Russian and Chinese intelligence services. That's a major crime in any society, in every nation, throughout all of history.