I'm not saying this proves that the Democrats are better, but I do think it's too simplistic to say that every single party in the world is exactly as corrupt/authoritarian as every other party in the world.
[0] https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/21449634/republicans...
B: "a survey of 2000 experts from around the world" is not a valid way to collect such data
And finally the actual article says:
"Its closest peers are, almost uniformly, radical right and anti-democratic parties. This includes Turkey’s AKP (a regime that is one of the world’s leading jailers of journalists), and Poland’s PiS (which has threatened dissenting judges with criminal punishment)."
Since concluding the Republican party is like those is ridiculous on it's face, one can only conclude this survey is garbage if it generates such results.
To be specific: the survey isn't measuring how the Republican party actually is. Rather it's measuring how these experts think the Republican party is - informed mainly by a liberal American media.
I've seen it over and over: Decide how you think the opponent will behave, then criticize them, in advance, as if they have already behaved that way.
Think about it: Do you think Republicans would "jail journalists" and "threaten judges with criminal punishment"? Next, think Did Republicans actually do that? And consider why your opinion on what you think they would do doesn't match what they actually did.
Whereas we, on the other hand, are only the second leading jailer of citizens.
> which has threatened dissenting judges with criminal punishment
Our current President repeatedly threatens journalists and the media with criminal punishment, tying your two points together.
Nope. He verifiably does not. The only time Trumps sued the press was when Melania sued Daily Mail for libel. Daily Mail lost and paid her $2.9M. https://www.snopes.com/news/2017/04/12/daily-mail-melania-tr...
If Trump sued for libel every time (which, IMO, he should, to provide some negative feedback to the system that's otherwise unstable), he'd put half the press in the country out of business by now.
https://cpj.org/reports/2020/04/trump-media-attacks-credibil...
So forgive us if we take "The press are the enemy of the people" from Trump with a grain of salt, when his sentiments are more accurately "The press that don't support me, the President, unequivocally and uncritically, are the enemy of the people".
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-48696131
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politic...
https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/m7jw5p/the-white-house-is...
Argumentum ad hominem.
> Since concluding the Republican party is like those is ridiculous on it's face,
Why?
> Do you think Republicans would "jail journalists" and "threaten judges with criminal punishment"?
They may not (yet) be doing those specific things. However, the article goes on to state which "anti-democratic" things they're actually doing:
"Over the past decade and a half, Republicans have shown disdain for procedural fairness and a willingness to put the pursuit of power over democratic principles. They have implemented measures that make it harder for racial minorities to vote, render votes from Democratic-leaning constituencies irrelevant, and relentlessly blocked Democratic efforts to conduct normal functions of government."
There are additional examples of this in the article:
"For example, Republicans won about 50 percent of the US House vote in North Carolina in 2018’s election. That translated into 70 percent of House seats due to heavily gerrymandered districts. Wisconsin Democrats won every statewide election in 2018 but did not win majorities in either chamber of the state legislature. While Democrats are also at a disadvantage due to concentration in urban areas, gerrymanders share much of the blame."
"North Carolina Rep. David Lewis, who chaired the state redistricting committee that put together a map so racially contorted that it was struck down in court in 2016, openly professed the power politics behind extreme gerrymandering in a speech on the statehouse floor."
"Lewis is notable mostly for his unusual honesty. Republicans believe they ought to win elections, and are doing everything in the power to make that the case — including changing the rules to stack the playing field in the favor. The effect is a party committed to an anti-democratic creed outside the norm of advanced Western democracies that insists that it is the true guardian of American democracy."
Unlike your assertion that these experts are only going off what "liberal media" tells them, they seem to be looking at what's actually happening. And it's deeply concerning.
Exactly. As I said, they are being rated based on what people like you think they will do, not what they actually do.
And you did the exact same thing. Are you even aware you did that?
Comparing Republicans to Turkey’s AKP or Poland’s PiS is absurd on it's face, yet vox doesn't seem aware of that.
And "Argumentum ad hominem" is not a valid rebuttal here, because every word vox says on this subject can not be taken as fact, yet you have quoted large sections of it. Even the study they have quoted can not be used, because vox chose the study to quote.
Saying "vox isn't a valid news source for this kind of news" is another way of saying "you need to start over if you want to analyze Republicans", this vox article is not a valid starting point.
> The problem with the vox article is it's rating the Republicans based on their image (specifically their image with liberal media), not their actions. And you did the exact same thing. Are you even aware you did that?
If you read my entire comment, or the entire article, you'll find that to not be the case. The rating is based entirely on actions, not "liberal media reporting".
Check slide 24 here, the US Democrats are on almost exactly the same spot as the Swedish Social Democrats (edit or look at 25, it is clearer):
https://www.dropbox.com/s/oidnej45mx6tyei/Global%20Party%20S...
It’s similar to how Apple can value privacy more because they are a hardware company.
You could look at this cynically and say that these organizations are all amoral agents who only behave according to their incentives. You’d be right. Another way to look at it is that these organizations are tools for humans, and their differing constraints mold them to be useful to further certain values. I don’t naively support democrats because I believe they are better people. I support them because their values align better with the world I want to live in.
In fact, every person is simply motivated to maximize comfort, minimize pain and procreate. It's a rat race through and through. All people are the same. Child killers and doctors. No difference.
Any simple extension of your miserable idea seems foolish. I'd hate to have to live in your mind.
If you only know the GOP and DNC i can understand why you'd think that
Political parties don't do anything, people in them do. The people in those parties, for the most part, do indeed have limits to what they will do to win. The ones that don't are sociopaths who unfortunately sometimes amass undeserved power. But I see no evidence for the kind of universal assertion of amorality you're making here.
> No political party anywhere on earth has principles above getting elected.
That just treats politics as some kind of nihilistic team sport, which I reject and it's unsupported by any evidence. Parties have platforms. According to https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/trust-us-politicians-ke... politicians do try to keep most of their platform promises.
> If you believe the democrats are any better, perhaps research machine politics.
I don't understand your point here. It appears that you're defending Republicans doing... something? By saying that the Democrats did... something?
> It is a naked power struggle from top to bottom on all sides.
That stance seems in direct contradiction to the enlightenment principles upon which the United States was founded. The peaceful transition of power between opposing parties has been very much a hallmark of the US republic for many decades, and a principle to which most of us adhere.
I think he's explicitly NOT defending either party. a critique of one is not a defense of the other.