Hacker News Reader

Comment by roenxi | Hacker News Reader

What is interesting is I'm not sure how many commenters of the video listened to it. The actual points she raised were mostly focused on "why would Pythagoras have used algebra?". And the answer as far as I can see is he probably didn't. Most of the notation we use was introduced in the 1600s-1700s [0].

The concepts we are taught today, and the way we are taught them, would be foreign to Pythagoras. According to wiki, symbolic algebra only emerged in 1200+ with the Arabs (which probably links to why we don't use Greek by default for algebra but we do with geometry).

[0]] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_mathematical_notati...

View on HN

Pythagoras didn't use modern algebraic notation, but I don't think it's correct to conclude from this that what he was doing wasn't algebra. He reasoned about relationships between abstract quantities in ways that we today would write down in algebraic notation. Does a change of notation mean that the reasoning itself is no longer algebra?

The ancient Greeks did stuff by example, not using algebra. They said stuff like, "take 22 and multiply by 5..." with actual numbers involved, then at the end they say "and that's how it works in general". So it's up to the reader to generalize from the specific. Algebra works in the opposite direction, where the reader is obliged to specify from the generic. I happen to much prefer the ancient Greek way of doing mathematics, but it seems to have fallen out of fashion.

"The ancient Greeks" are certainly not a homogeneous group. Here's Euclid's proof of the Pythagorean theorem: https://mathcs.clarku.edu/~djoyce/java/elements/bookI/propI4...

There are no concrete quantities in sight. I don't think that they were removed by the translator. Much more plausibly the original reasoning was symbolic in the way indicated here. Though again, possibly using different notation.

Sorry, I think I was referring specifically to the dude that did integer polynomial equations. His name starts with P i think.

Ah, you might be thinking of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diophantine_equation. Sure enough, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diophantus says: "It should be mentioned here that Diophantus never used general methods in his solutions. Hermann Hankel, renowned German mathematician made the following remark regarding Diophantus. “Our author (Diophantos) not the slightest trace of a general, comprehensive method is discernible; each problem calls for some special method which refuses to work even for the most closely related problems. For this reason it is difficult for the modern scholar to solve the 101st problem even after having studied 100 of Diophantos’s solutions”." I didn't know this, thanks.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com