Tritium, however, does NOT exist in nature, and can only be conceivably produced in three ways:
1. Inside thermonuclear bombs
2. In heavy-water reactors, e.g. CANDU design, which requires Uranium, so it is not fuel-independent and totally dependent on nuclear fission technology. Getting Tritium that way is also extremely, extremely expensive.
3. possibly, in a breeding blanket of a fusion reactor. This makes fusion technology reliant on breeding reactors which is much more complicated and has many completely unsolved questions in the materials part. Also, existing fission-breeding reactors are also less safe, for example, like the Japanese Monju plant, which was cooled with liquid sodium, a highly reactive metal, which got incensed in a fire. Fusion breeder reactors will probably also require something like sodium cooling because of the high energy densities required.
And the existing research projects like ITER have not even started to address these issues - they are purely plasma physics experiments.
Section 3.2 Test Blanket Module (TBM) Testing Program in ITER
https://www.iter.org/doc/www/content/com/Lists/ITER%20Techni...
Look even closer at the fusion energy research community and you will find a lot of work has already gone into this problem. Assuming physicists sit on their thumbs is a bad bet.
Maybe I don't understand properly, but I'm watching the video linked in a previous comment (1) and around the minute 9:30 professor White says that "what comes into the plant is actually deuterium and lithium".
It seems he is saying that you need only an initial quantity of Tritium and then Helium and Lithium is used to created Tritium again. I suppose that it's what you refer as "breeding". He explain it as it's not a big deal.
Not fissionable, but many are unacceptable due to formation of long lived activtion products.
One additional problem with the alloys used is the degradation of their mechanical properties under radiation exposure. They tend to become brittle.
Testing any of these materials will require something close to a working fusion reactor (nothing else duplicates the neutron environment), but that will require the materials. Working around this loop of circular development dependency will be time consuming.
Given the amount of energy that comes from fusion fuel, even extracting lithium from seawater would probably be economical.
Beryllium is much less common so that could be an issue. But maybe we can find more beryllium if we look harder; right now we barely use it. If we can't find enough, we could probably design a reactor to use lead instead. Either one acts as a neutron multiplier, and General Fusion's design uses lead instead of beryllium, for the same purpose.