“The Social Dilemma” Fails to Tackle the Real Issues in Tech
slate.com
slate.com
I'm very very grateful that the film exists, and for the conversation it's started. But I agree with this assessment. The film paints a dark picture and then leaves viewers on their own to figure out what to do-- beyond maybe taking their kid's phones away.
I disagree with TFA's notion that diversity at tech companies would help address the core problems of intrusive surveillance tech. Only stronger countervailing social institutions can do that.
To take my own medicine: vote, ask your representatives for regulation, use your technical expertise to draft bills or run for office, engage your community on issues that matter.
The algorithms deployed serve a simple purpose.... find a rabbit hole near where they measure your position in the space of ideas... and tilt what you see towards it... then measure how long you stay down there.... optimizing for maximum time in the hole.
The solution is simple, switch to systems where you decide what you're going to pay attention to. RSS, Blogs, human curated communications.
You might still fall into a rabbit hole that leads to extremism, but at least there won't be a billionaire incentivized to push you into it. Society, on the other hand, and normal social pressures, should be sufficient to help you find your way back out.
Yes, economic inequality is a major issue and ‘intersects’ with everything.
But the dynamics of social networks are absolutely a problem independent of that, and it’s important for people to be able to reason about that without collapsing it into ‘capitalism bad’.
Money == food,water and shelter
If you are saying that a person who actually doesn’t have access to food, water, and shelter don’t have time to think about the problems of social media, I’d say there is merit to that.
But then that seems like a clear ‘yes’ to my question.
It also supports my original comment about how terrible the piece is.
By your logic, someone in such a position can’t or shouldn’t be reading a Slate article discussing the relative importance of these issues.
Code that unifies the user and customer models are likely to be more "user friendly" given they don't put a priority on growth of a model that lies outside the user model. Those types of models can focus on what the users want, collectively, and may even profit from making the user's lives better from the use of the product.
If anyone here has built or maintained an app and that app has separate user and customer models, then you are part of this problem!
I still think the underlying problem is profit though, since these companies offer free product in order to get the largest user base (since social networks benefit from this scale). Maximizing user base size leads to more profit since they have more and larger media, politician, and advertising customers. Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram would not be anywhere near as successful if all the users were required to pay a subscription fee.
It's an inherent contradiction between social networks and profit that cannot, in my view at least, be resolved.
Also, I never implied that broadcast TV doesn't have it's own subset of issues. I actually think broadcast TV has a few big problems. It moves from manufactured panic to panic, limits the acceptable discourse in order to be subservient to its donors and funding sources (people with certain political opinions never get a platform), and it benefits in a similar way to social media from social division and disfunction. Media manufactures moral panic and plays in a similar way on human emotion in order to keep viewers watching so that they can make more money.
> The American model of advertisement funded broadcast proved them wrong and American broadcast industry grew by bounds and leaps while the British were stunted despite the television set being invented in Britain.
I mean maybe we should be asking ourselves "at what cost?" and "who benefited from that?". A bunch of media execs got rich, but did broader society really benefit? It's easy to always defer to "growth" as good and completely ignore the costs.
In the absence of shareholders or a profit motive, the networks would have the same capacity to influence and manipulate, and so there would still be an incentive for people to seek to control them to obtain this power, for which money is just a proxy.
There is no counterfactual ‘on their own’ to compare to.
I think we absolutely should be thinking about how to mitigate the incentive problems, which is exactly why I think the article is bad.
See kordlessagain’s comment which is a peer to mine here. I don’t necessarily think kordlessagain is right (although they may be), but this is exactly the kind of constructive thinking the article is discouraging, which is why I see it as so terrible.
A world where profit is not the motive, honestly sounds great to me, but it’s not a real counterfactual unless someone explains how it would work.
Without such an explanation it’s like talking about a world where nobody needs to eat. You can imagine it would be good, and somehow possible in some sci-fi future, but there are no actual examples.
It’s important to be able to think critically and with nuance, of course, why must avoiding “harming capitalism” when capitalism causes tons of harm across contexts of science and culture, be avoided?
It’s not a person it’s ideological guidelines. Surely jabbing at any ideology as frequently as the public wishes must be tolerated in a free society.
So why the boxing in and protectionism of capitalism at all? Whatever this reality is it’s obviously only moving towards it’s destruction.
Why should clinging to historical emotional objects be a priority of our critical thinking education in a universe smashing itself apart?
Why capitalism? Or Catholicism? Certainly other frameworks would achieve a similar statistical balance of haves versus have nots, since real logistical distribution mirrors monarchism, and other historical hierarchies.
If that’s what we’re going for, why the pretense? Just legislate gamed logistical distribution as a goal. No need for syntactic jargon unless the real goal is obscurantism.
Numbers don’t lie: capitalism is just another generational emotional game, obligation to defer to hierarchy, like the others humanity binned. What’s so important about it?
Why are you talking about ‘not harming capitalism’? What has that got to do with anything?