Has anyone (DigitalOcean, Github or others) run numbers on what percentage of casual users are converted into persistent open-source contributors while initially being incentivized by Hacktoberfest? Sure spam is and always will be a problem, but if that first number is significant (of course that's a big if) then it makes sense to encourage this effort by putting in some moderation overtime. As I mentioned elsewhere in the thread I'd very gladly sift through a mountain of spam if it meant getting another reliable maintainer or two for my project.