[0] https://www.elmundo.es/cataluna/2019/04/25/5cc192b4fdddff712...
[1] http://convivenciacivicacatalana.blogspot.com/p/administraci...
[0] https://www.elmundo.es/cataluna/2019/04/25/5cc192b4fdddff712...
[1] http://convivenciacivicacatalana.blogspot.com/p/administraci...
Spain is not a single nation, its a state with several historical nationalities.
So the use of "[action] deterred from [region the action might occur in" was surprising and possibly incorrect. If you'd said "[...] deterred in [...]", it would have been perfectly grammatical English.
It's a weird nit to pick in such harsh language, especially on a comment section that's more likely than the typical HN comment page to attract people who are not native English speakers.
Spanish is the main language in Spain, the only spoken by everybody, therefore can be inferred easily that X = Spanish
Having this in mind, 'Y' can be inferred easily also.
"the idea that Spanish should be deterred from [being used in] part of a territory is surrealist"
Territory means 'Spain' in this context.
Hope this helps
Definition of deter
transitive verb
1 : to turn aside, discourage, or prevent from acting
she would not be deterred by threats
2 : inhibit
painting to deter rust
I have also seen "crime" and "war" given in examples of sense 2. To "deter the language", in sense 2, would be to deter speakers from using the language. You can sort of unify the two senses by treating "rust" or "war" or "crime" as willful entities - but in that case I don't see a reason you couldn't do the same for a language.Do you actually fail to understand what pvaldes was trying to communicate?