It turns out that masks are far more effective than flu shots, so no, I'm not going to get a flu shot. Anyway, IIRC, "kills thousands of people each year" is a statistical projection that doesn't actually stand up to scrutiny. Certainly, it's nothing like COVID-19.
>There was a lot of debate about masks.
There was a lot of misinformation spread because of the failure to stockpile PPE. That misinformation is still doing harm now because the MAGA folks are running around saying "masks don't work"
>I don't know what you're implying by the phrase 'argument by authority,' but we're talking about people who have spent their entire careers in the field of medicine. Normally we call those people 'scientists' and 'experts.'
Unfortunately, medical experts credibility is now shot by spreading false information about masks, and by downplaying the risk of COVID-19 in January and February by telling everybody to get a flu shot. Then I wonder how many people died on ventilators when intubated on MAX ..
As a group you're weren't operating at the level of Dennis Richie or Donald Knuth, so you have work to do to regain credibility.
In fact, you're still not now. You should focus less on evidence-based medicine and more on risk asymmetry. Mask wearing (even of cloth masks) had very little downside and a potentially huge upside. But we had to wait for evidence. The same is true of vitamin-D now. Look for low-risk interventions. If we don't have the resources to mass test the at-risk population, we should encourage those on poor diets to take 1000IU a daythis winter. But we will have to wait until next year for evidence.