Both public and private companies can have business models that are driven by the morality of their founders and key employees but it’s still a business model.
Cygnus wasn’t more moral than say Oracle, they just had developed a business model around FOSS services that was unique, since they didn’t held any IP they didn’t had the tools that some people may consider immoral such as protecting their patents through law suits or worse rent seeking based on IP they hold.
Same goes for other companies today that primarily rely on FOSS software I don’t consider Ubuntu, Red Hat (even before the acquisition) or even Purism to be “moral” companies just because they can’t or don’t hammer someone with law suits or rake in royalties.
I also don’t consider opposition to companies that do to be a simple moral issue. I can and do have my own opinions about companies that I feel practice more rent seeking than actual innovation or any sort of productive activity but I don’t see it to be a particularly moral stance to want them to go into financial trouble because in the end the losers will be their employees and shareholders.
I much rather see companies like Oracle for example be successful based on true productivity than go into financial trouble.
But companies are run by people. I think it's easier to think that companies are more like profit robots to get past our qualms of what we expect of humans, but in the end they are made of and run by humans. So much ink of US history has been used to write about corporate scandals and the profiteering that we just come to expect it -- notably the 2008 recession was caused by pure unadulterated greed on a vast scale.
JPMC plead guilty to three felonies and basically got a handslap. Talk about moral hazard!
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/time-for-three-strikes-an_b_7...
PS. You might think that $35B is a large fine, but they have $3T under management.
https://www.google.com/search?q=JPMC+assets+under+management...
What most morals are is boils down to what behavior is acceptable and beneficial or to be more exact the set of incentives and repercussions that society enforces.
No one can really argue that downloading a movie or a songs is an objectively moral act, however most people can easily justify it as a victimless crime, some even justify it by claiming that the entertainment industry itself is immoral.
What you essentially have is people with targets and an incentive structure that is misaligned with what you or society at large consider to be moral.
If a business can make a large sum of money by doing something against the rules and the punishment is smaller than the profits it will essentially always lead to “amoral” behavior.
Until we can actually deprive bad acting companies of the ability to influence the political landscape, nothing is going to stand a significant chance of actually making a misalignment of moral/legal compass hurt.
You are distinguishing between Microsoft the corporation and persons who might rehabilitate, although how I read your sentence, I infer that you consider Microsoft a person, only a different kind of person to human beings.
I don't know if I'm right about how I read you, but I think I can comment usefully on a different distinction which I think is the most important one necessary to make in these kinds of comparisons:
A company is a legal person.
But it is unhelpful to think about a corporate person in terms with which you might regard a human being.
I find it very much clearer to think about the body corporate as taking on the character and nature bestowed upon it by its directing executive management / board.
Certainly it is by this means that any company has ever acquired a psychopathy.
AS several comments also say in different ways, the caveat is that once you replace the human animus that directs the behaviour of the company, you can completely change the behaviour of a corporate being.
What I think is being conflated here frequently is the organisational behavioural properties of any large organisations that have vestigial and inhibiting effect on corporate body character redefining changes.
These things are always something that I have to carefully unpick whenever you want to avoid confusing myself and that's after 35 years of analysing corporate beings looking for long term bets. It's not easy or at least it never got easier for me. I wish I could weigh in on the issue which I think everyone cares about most : the sincerity of Microsoft and even the question of whether Microsoft is capable of sincerity. So far I can only agree with a tangential comment made last week, how the old evil Microsoft at least sure documented everything far better. If they documented like the Technet I remember, for the whole WSL game, now that might convince me they mean well towards the open world. But somehow I think Microsoft embraced and only extended the documentation shame...
Usually you try to stay as far away from that person as you can. If they want redemption they should find it with a new set of people. They set that bridge on fire while we asked them not to. They watched it burn. They gloated the entire time. The ashes have washed away but many of us remember.
Microsoft Office for Mac was first released 31 years ago. It’s nothing new and hence is orthogonal to anyone’s subjective impression of Microsoft’s engagement in EEE.
Microsoft has been the largest ISV in the Apple ecosystem by far, for decades.
I have to imagine that that was an innocent typo. Do you think so? Or do you think that it wasn’t, and so pointing it out helps to discredit the author?
Habitual abusers of relationship always promise that they will be better the next time and for a few days they are indeed better behaved. After a while they fall back to the same patterns
I don't know about Microsoft though - the CEO changed, but what about the rest?
The leadership (both the board and the executives) have changed since that time. I assume you also refuse to buy BMW and Volkswagen cars and actively petition governments worldwide to boycott them because "the company" supported the Nazi's during WWII?
Same with Toyota, Mitsubishi, Hitachi, etc?
If Microsoft bankrolling the SCO lawsuits is the stand you want to take then be my guest. It was almost 20 years ago, the entire leadership of the company has changed, their culture has changed, and they are pretty much unrecognizable at this point.
So, I'm already "boycotting" almost every company you listed, without even needing any ideological goal to chase after. The fact is these giant evil mega-conglomerates aren't that great at making things. The more you avoid them the better off you will be.
Now, everything is connected to everything else, so I think the following rules are reasonable for avoiding evil companies:
- If it's a commodity, and it's mixed in with all the other commodities, it's probably not practical to separate the tainted stuff from the cleanly produced stuff.
- If it's a specific company with a specific product that they have specifically done evil stuff to push, that's an example of something to avoid.
- If the same people are in power as when the company was evil, it's probably still evil. If everything but the name has changed maybe they can get another chance. For degrees of change in-between those two, use your judgement.
He joined the company in 1992, when it was as bad as it got and did not see any reason to go work somewhere else. He was totally free to pack up and go but choose to hold on and continued to work there all the way up to today. That makes him at a minimum a silent supporter and at worst complicit. Neither of these speak well for his ethics.
Nadella gave up his Greencard to switch to the H-1B program in 1994 to bring his wife to the US (and surely this unprecedented switch was some time in the making). Subsequently he relied on Microsoft to sponsor him once again for permanent residency.
In that situation no immigrants switches employers regardless of their ethics. It often isn't even possible to make such a switch.
You're certainly entitled to your opinion, but I think it's a little silly to write them off over old stuff that they're no longer engaged in when there are bigger fish to fry. They are making pretty good products these days and, by all appearances, are one of the better players in big tech these days.
I hated Microsoft back then too. They were about as bad as I thought a company could be. At least until I lived long enough to see Amazon, Google and Facebook - or learned about the horrible things other household brands have done.