This could be quite awesome. Only thing is, I have a hunch the comments will be of Youtube quality.
What would be fantastic is if Google could weight these votes based on how "alike" the person voting for it is to me.
EG, if I was interested in say, Kung Fu and Knitting, and there were other people interested in Kung Fu and Knitting, then the options that they vote for would be more relevant to me than someone who was doing SEO work on those various sites. So hopefully those would rank higher.