In Dune, Paul Atreides led a jihad, not a crusade
aljazeera.com
aljazeera.com
>JIHAD: a religious crusade; fanatical crusade.
>JIHAD, BUTLERIAN: (see also Great Revolt)—the crusade against computers, thinking machines, and conscious robots begun in 201 B.G. and concluded in 108 B.G.
Until now, I only knew the character of "Serena Butler" instead, coming from the more recent Brian Herbert's & Kevin J. Anderson's prequel novels. This one actually: https://dune.fandom.com/wiki/Serena_Butler
Another trait of such a rich universe, indeed!
"Today, only 43% of Americans identify as white and Christian, and only 30% as white and Protestant."
"Nearly one in four (24%) Americans are now religiously unaffiliated."
And it's going in a pretty clear direction.
"Conversely, only about one-quarter of young adults (age 18-29) belong to a white Christian tradition, including white evangelical Protestant (8%), white mainline Protestant (8%), or white Catholic (6%)."
https://www.prri.org/research/american-religious-landscape-c...
From the article:
"Unlike many of his, or our, contemporaries, Herbert was willing to imagine a world that was not based on Western, Christian mythology."
I would say, rather, now more than any other recent time in American history, people are 'willing to imagine a world that was not based on Western, Christian mythology.'
The author works on Sufism at UPenn (which is undoubtedly fascinating - would love to sign up for one of his classes), but I think he might benefit from looking at the world through a lens that isn't colored exclusively by religion.
If you look at conservative Hollywood, it hasn't. Arabs and/or Muslim are still the obvious baddies in the cultural representation of the USA centric view of the world through the film industry in North America.
I think we're moving away from it.
Maybe I just haven't seen enough new movies though, that could definitely be a possibility.
It’s got some cool imagery, but it’s not like some kind of profound wisdom that needs to be safeguarded.
The first novel was never intended by Herbert to be "self-contained", but the second novel never achieved the same popularity as the first — perhaps for obvious reasons, if you've read it. It's not the sequel one expects.
Friends have pushed me to read the rest of the Dune books, but I'm reluctant. Not because the story is unexpected -- that sounds promising, actually -- but because if it's not well-written, it would feel like it taints them gem I already know.
It's a little surprising to me that readers would be demanding what they expect from the books. The whole point of Dune is that politics is a multi-layered process of wheels within wheels within wheels. It should come as no surprise that everything would turn out to be a head fake -- that's so much of the enjoyment of it.
Agreed, that's a fair characterization.
The Missionaria Protectiva is referenced at quite a few points in the novels. It's never explained in too much depth, but it's clear that Herbert was not proposing that indigenous tribes have some inherent propensity to follow a white savior. The acceptance also certainly is not instant, Paul has to demonstrate facility with numerous Fremen customs and show his leadership chops over a period of years before he comes to lead them. The task is only really complete when he becomes the first male successfully to transmute the Water of Life.
David Brin has some good think pieces about how 'Dune' is a warning and why the Atreides are not the good guys of the novels (at least, not at first).
Right. The Bene Gesserit had spent millennia spreading "myths" (AKA propaganda) throughout various societies for their own purposes, i.e., "politics". Herbert is alluding to how mythology and religion have always been exploited to serve the selfish interests of those in power.
Was it Europe-like? ISTR that it was a water world, and exported rice.
> "Unlike many of his, or our, contemporaries, Herbert was willing to imagine a world that was not based on Western, Christian mythology."
Again, who cares?
The post is basically saying "book that was massively popular at the time and is still popular actually holds up quite well when examined with current sensibilities in mind".
It's also saying "don't jettison one of the things that make it great even when examined with contemporary sensibilities".
It's the opposite of a takedown, and given that this sort of judgement is the exception rather than the rule[0], it's nice to have confirmation that I can continue to recommend Dune to new readers.
So, I care.
[0] I still love the LotR for example, but it is rather racist, quite overtly in places.
Just wait until they read the passage in Dune Messiah where Paul compares himself to Hitler and Genghis Khan, while Stilgar and Korba refuse to believe it.