The app could easily ask you to check a checkbox next to each scope, and then write separate code for each combination of checkboxes. They decided not to do that because it's probably not worth your business if you don't want to give them full access. (Honestly, I click a lot of things on HN that ask for way too many scopes, and then I close the window and forget what it was. But the calculation was done -- they don't need me as a user or customer. I can live with that.)
I guess what people want is an IDP that will give applications fake data when you deny a scope. But no application developer wants to deal with that complexity, so they'd never integrate a provider that does that. (They probably moved away from email+password because of all the fake emails that people provide.)
On the other hand, it's mandatory for iOS apps to use Apple's sign-in which auto-generates a fake email address for you. So I suppose some progress is being made. (I have an iPhone but I've never seen this supposedly mandatory OAuth provider. I only know about it from reading HN. So maybe it doesn't actually exist? I have no idea really.)
I also don't think people want an IDP that provides fake data when you deny a scope. That's a bad implementation IMHO. When you say no that means you don't authorize access for that scope, not that send fake data. Applications should deal with it.
I'm actually working on an open-source IDP in my spare time, and to me this sounds like something to seriously consider doing right. I appreciate the idea and the discussion. I doubt anyone in the real world will care, though. (Sometimes you need to get the early adopters that do care about these things, though :)
I once tried to sign-up with Google an it asked me to allow (with no option to deny but continue) to share my specific personal details. I've cancelled and never used this technology ever since. I didn't have to specify the same details (which Google was going to share) when signing-up with an e-mail address.
The spec should discourage sharing details beyond necessary, prevent any details from being shared silently and ensure user can always deny and continue.
And there's nothing they could write in the spec to deny that besides a perfunctory "please don't do that" which companies could ignore without consequence.
However, that’s really about OpenID, not about OAuth.
The problem is that you can't make _everything_ optional, or else the user can deny everything and the application then has to tell the user "You denied X, but we really need it to proceed. Try again...", which is a definitively worse experience than having the grant request say "here's what this app is asking for".
This is like Android allowing apps to ask for permissions they don't "need" because, well surveillance and user data brokerage is the business model that most are info and the reason many apps are "free" or "cheap" in the first place, crowding out more honest business models.
Maybe there could be an initiative for apps and sites without predatory practices, like "apps/webs needing no personal info from you"