Re-breathing your own expelled air is provably bad for health.
Re-breathing your own expelled air is provably bad for health.
On the other hand, wearing a mask does prevent particulate transmission, which is provably good for other people's health.
Would you be able to provide any reliable evidence to your claim?
Surgeons wearing masks for a period of time during an operation is not the same thing. But I would expect that those surgeons that wear masks the most would suffer with dental issues, sores, and breathing issues. Are you able to prove that there are no deleterious effects?
Its not proven that masks prevents particulate transmission. Can you provide reliable evidence for your claim?
And to governments now, can you provide that evidence before you start enforcing mandates please? And, why the evidence is so patchy - no distancing or masks in Sweden. Sometimes masks are mandatory and advised, then sometimes not. Its mixed messaging because there is no evidence.
This is not a logical conclusion. However, in Japanese culture, people wear masks by choice when they are ill. So it's not universal that people don't choose to wear masks.
> Are you able to prove that there are no deleterious effects?
That's not how it works - the side making a claim has to provide evidence.
> Its not proven that masks prevents particulate transmission. Can you provide reliable evidence for your claim?
CDC - https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/prevent-getting-si...
Mayo Clinic - https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/coronavirus/i...
UCSF - https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2020/06/417906/still-confused-abou...
> Its mixed messaging because there is no evidence
It's mixed messaging because this was a novel virus, and we didn't know how to deal with it at first. Also, with shortage supplies, the initial guidance was focused on ensuring sufficient PPE would be available to medical workers. Finally, it's a very complex situation - looking at something in isolation is reductionist and doesn't help with understanding.
> That's not how it works - the side making a claim has to provide evidence.
Lol! Who is making the claim? Is it me who's saying that we should be able to breath as nature intended (without masks)? Or you who's saying that we should wear masks? Who has to prove their case do you think?!?
And a breaking story - "Covid-19 study on mask-wearing efficacy rejected by journals"
https://www.rt.com/news/504219-danish-mask-study-rejected-co...
No one will publish the study...
You are making the claim that masks hinder respiration. This has not been supported by evidence, theoretical or outcome based. What is your hypothesis for the mechanism? We know that gases diffuse through the material.
> No one will publish the study... The fact that a single study is problematic - without specifying why it's problematic, and without any mention of the many other studies - is not a very strong discussion point.
I appreciate the time you put in, but I think we're so far apart that I don't see any reason to continue this thread.
The mandatory mask wearing is anti-peace, anti-life, anti-'all the good stuff mentioned above'. And governments have made this mandatory in many places. I can't think of something more anti-life than restricting free breathing.
Governments are mandating anti-life activity, and this is accepted!
This has been rolled out and is encouraged by most. Its even actually considered ok to shame and snitch on others who don't accept it.
For me, the mask 'cure' is worse than the disease. How many people will suffer known health effects from wearing masks, for the sake of the unproven hypothesis that they mitigate something?
I don't understand those on this thread who are happy to upvote the nice comments, while overlooking the elephant in the room. Perhaps you didn't recognise it as the mask is covering its whole trunk!!
None? Or they are probably already in a physical state in which going out in public during a pandemic is not a good idea?