Hacker News Reader

Fine, but if we couldn't, does she have a point about the priorities, and if not, why not?

(And, BTW, the fact that some investment has a good ROI doesn't mean you should pick it over another with a higher ROI)

View on HN

I honestly don’t think she is qualified to speak on the priorities of a discipline she has never been involved in. They will do and prioritise what they think is reasonable based on fierce internal discussions and consensus building. I personally was never taken by the prospect of working on a huge project like the various experiments at LHC or any of the successors. If you defund HEP these people won’t magically go work on something else together. A large pool of people will simply stop doing physics and dissipate. Let them do what they want, it has worked out pretty well so far. There is plenty of other research that is well funded and competing for talent and attention. Why give up on something where Europe has clear worldwide leadership.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com