Good Quality DOSBox Video Capture
susam.in
susam.in
Not how copyright works. The author of the post is not the copyright holder of the screenshots (in the usa). They are either inelligible (simple commandline interfaces), or the aurhor of the computer program being screenshoted is the copyright holder.
More importantly, because its bad business to sue your users who are providing you free advertising. In some cases twitch streaming may also be fair use. Many video game companies provide explicit permission to streamers to stream their video game - e.g. https://www.xbox.com/en-us/developers/rules
Twitch is also different because now both the original video game and the streamer both have a copyright of the result, where in the screenshot case, the person creating the screenshot didn't add anything artistic, so they dont have any copyright added to the result. Remember in USA, copyright is based on if you put something artistic into the end result, not how hard you worked (other countries are different, google sweat of the brow)
Wikimedia commons aims to be a repository of stuff that you can definitely use no matter what, without worrying that maybe the heir to some video game designer from the 80s comes out of hiding and makes a fuss. The images are still allowed on wikipedia, they just can't be in that section (think of it like the difference between debian main and debian non-free)
My intention here is to make these screenshots that I took on my computer while playing the game available on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digger_(video_game), so that this Wikipedia article contains a few screenshots of the original 1983 PC booter version of Digger, not just that of the 1998 remastered version.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Software_screenshots...
More importantly, the law is the law, and it's bad business to detract from that fact.
Twitch isn't any different than the screenshot case... it took art to load the DOSBox programs... sending the right input signals to the various programs to allow the screenshot to be taken.
> More importantly, the law is the law, and it's bad business to detract from that fact.
Not really. When you get away from the Free Software hippies (i say that endaringly as one of them) who want freedom from copyright, the way religious people want purity, copyright is largely about risk management.
> Twitch isn't any different than the screenshot case...
There's lots of differences (in both directions). Lots of twitch has explicit permission to use the video games, most of twitch isn't streaming abandonware, the argument for fair use is probably present for both but much easier to make for wikipedia, etc. In terms of wikipedia, the concern is ideological purity, not that some defunct video game heir is going to come out of nowhere and sue us.
> it took art to load the DOSBox programs...
It took skill, not art. The screenshots themselves don't contain originality by the author of the post, so he doesn't get copyright of it in usa (european countries are often different). See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bridgeman_Art_Library_v._Corel.... I'm not sure how that relates to your point though. Even if the screenshots contained originality from the author, like how twitch streams do, it doesn't remove the copyright from the original video game designer, it would just mean both have a copyright and you would need permission from both to do stuff with the created work.
Disclaimer: IANAL
Title 17 wasn't written as an MBA business plan template... it was written as law.
The legal system isn't boolean.
Copyright exists to support and encourage certain businesses that would not be viable without it. Specifically, copyright supports some businesses where the cost to create the first item (e.g., book, music, video game) is very high, but the cost required to replicate the item is very low.
Copyright law gives options to rights holders that they can consider using to enforce their rights. In cases where infringers are clearly interfering with their business (e.g., selling or giving away copies of their work), then the rights holder may choose to sue for infringement. In the case of streamers on Twitch where the infringement may lead to increased interest in their product, they may choose to do nothing.
Some remastered it, the Windows version is still playable on x64 Windows 7, presumably also on Win10: https://www.digger.org/download.html