[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Socialist_Party_of_Am...
edit: downvoted to hell, predictably. Everyone loves freedoms, unless they are of something they dislike
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Socialist_Party_of_Am...
edit: downvoted to hell, predictably. Everyone loves freedoms, unless they are of something they dislike
Freedom, liberty have limits. The limits are cultural and ruled by law. In France, the freedom of speech must respect individuals and allows to mock ideas and ideologies. And religions are ideologies.
If people feel offended when their ideas are criticized or mocked, they are not supposed to kill: they have to adapt, or if in doubt they are personally attacked, they can address a tribunal to settle the case.
Liking a murder is not an opinion or a speech, it is personally attacking the victim and his relatives.
"Clearly Islam, if followed to the letter, is incompatible with the modern world (...) Hell, nor is Christianity, if taken literally."
Not sure about this: all religions have specificities and different reference texts. Of course christians and muslims are humans, and humans kill when reaching extreme conditions. However christians are in violation of their texts when killing.
Not in Islam: muslims are in line with their prophet life (hadith "who leaves the Religion, kill him!") and Koran, a book written by God himself. Koran is quite a bloody book describing severe rules, xenophobia for non-muslims, slaughters, slavery, explicitly allowing wife-beating... And being written by God, not a word can be challenged by moderates to stop extremists: they would just put themselves in the blasphemy list for being murdered.
Some muslims try to unlock Islam from these deadlocks. However it usually brings them to harsh times, a lifetime in jail in the best case (Raif Badawi), or being murdered (Mahmoud Mohammed Taha).
Sometimes it is important to make people uncomfortable in the name of progress. Sometimes people take advantage of that to be trolls. The two are inseparable and to a generic outside observer indistinguishable.
But the real reason for freedom of speech is purely to preserve individual liberty and remove any value judgement on the part of society. The only time it is ok to limit speech is when it poses a risk of real harm to others.
I'm not totally comfortable with this because it creates a situation in which people may be compelled to speak or reproduce the speech of others for the supposed benefit to society.
This is a very interesting perspective I will continue to consider.
> Several knives and other weapons were found at his home, prosecutor Frederic Chevallier.
Spare me. This has nothing to do with the technicalities of free speech. A right incidentally that Islamists who cut peoples heads off don't accept.
It is certainly rational to arrest someone for screaming they are about to kill rather than waiting for them to go through with it.
Was there another story?
> It is certainly rational to arrest
> someone for screaming they are
> about to kill
With you so far. But the guy in the story did not do that...> Several knives and other weapons were found at his home, prosecutor Frederic Chevallier.
I'm all for free speech and I understand slippery slopes and don't approve of thought policing. My reading of this article is that they had sufficient evidence to arrest him, technicalities and legalities aside.
Thought exercise - could you construct a hypothetical situation where you/he should be arrested? Clearly there is some line, some combination of evidence and circumstance which would allow justify an arrest and search.
And if they are mistaken for doing this and discover they overreacted I'm sure some lawyer will be glad to sue the French government on these technicalities and ensure heads would roll. ;)
The problem is not religion, it's that some fundamentalists who are not right in the head use it as an excuse to commit horrifying acts.
Yes, sure. Religion is super personal, it doesn't automatically mean you believe every word of a text. There may be some that demand that, but it's a broad spectrum that definitely admits looser interpretations.
It's the same with the Quran, the Torah, the Bardo Thodol. Religious text tend to have a lot of allegories and ambiguous texts that are ripe for different interpretations...
And someone who is religious could always easily claim that god may be perfect and omniscient but men are fallible and that the text has been imperfectly re transcribed over time (the oldest copy of the complete Bible, the Codex Vaticanus is from the 4th century for example).
But then again, I don't think in absolutes and that's why I'm an agnostic... I don't find any religion likely but I can't claim to know everything and be completely sure that there is no god, or entity or whatever.
Then of course you have quotes like "The LORD makes poor and makes rich; he brings low and he exalts.”... It's not like any religion is completely self-consistent.
Islam is worse because it claims the Quran is the literal word of God. That doesn't really allow for the reinterpretation gymnastics that Christians can do, because they at least acknowledge their book is written by man.
Tell this to all the gay and trans people who are very much killed in the streets in places like the US. (I'm not saying Christians do all the violence against lgbtq people or that all Christians are complicit in said violence. I'm just pointing out that the parent's claim that Christians don't do this any more is not correct.)
For an example of actual blasphemy that riled up a lot of Christians in the US, see Serrano's Piss Christ. Although to the best of my knowledge nobody was killed because of it.
Not all of these fit the bill, but it's a place to start your further research.
Did you make it up? Because that’s an extremely serious charge, and shouldn’t be made lightly. You cause more animosity and tension when you spread narratives that convince people that certain groups are out to murder them, and this can escalate into real violence.