Dark mode matters, but so does light mode. I think the option should always be there for your users, since it seems like the population is split pretty evenly in their preference for one over the other. Evangelizing for only one mode is missing the point in my opinion.
On a side note (and not to come off as spammy), but I built a front-end framework specifically to make it easy for web devs to include dark mode (along with light mode) in the tools and dashboards they build: https://www.gethalfmoon.com/