Inside the stacked RAM modules used in the Apple III
righto.com
righto.com
Curious about these reliability issues, this prompted me to read more about the Apple III on Wikipedia and it's quite interesting:
> There was way too short a time frame in manufacturing and development. When the decision was made to announce, there were only three Apple IIIs in existence, and they were all wire-wrapped boards.
> The case of the Apple III had long since been set in concrete, so they had a certain size logic board to fit the circuits on ... They went to three different outside houses and nobody could get a layout that would fit on the board.
> They used the smallest line circuit boards that could be used. They ran about 1,000 of these boards as preproduction units to give to the dealers as demonstration units. They really didn't work ... Apple swapped out the boards. The problem was, at this point there were other problems, things like chips that didn't fit. There were a million problems that you would normally take care of when you do your preproduction and pilot run. Basically, customers were shipped the pilot run.
- The machine supports a maximum of 512 kB of RAM.
- The 6502 zero-page can be relocated on the fly to anywhere in the 512 kB address space.
- Certain 6502 addressing modes can access the entire 512 kB address space without bank switching, where it otherwise would only be able to access 64 kB.
- The area of RAM reserved for the operating system and device drivers can be protected from regular apps.
- It also includes built-in RGB video at 280x192x16 colors, and a 6-bit DAC for sound.
But even without the initial reliability problems the machine probably didn't stand a chance in the market.
It fell in the trap of being simultaneously too much computer (too expensive for what it does) and not enough computer (not powerful enough for its rather complicated operating system). And its 8-bit architecture would be quickly eclipsed by 8086 and 68000-based machines, so it was both state of the art and outdated at the same time.
Apple was right in that they needed a machine that was significantly more powerful than the Apple II, but their timing was off and the architecture was wrong. The IBM PC did a much better job of hitting the sweet spot of price vs. power vs. complexity.
Though ultimately the tech got good enough. Another 20 years passed the G4 Cube we now have 5nm A14 on a Smartphone or iPad Air that are powerful enough for 80-90% of consumer use cases. All without a Fan. We also have a roadmap of 3nm and 2nm ~2025.
Unfortunately Steve did not live long enough to see it.
Jobs remained adamant that computers with fans were junk, so the original Macintosh also lacked a cooling fan, in spite of having an internal power supply, CRT, and supporting analog board. This presumably contributed to the large number of analog board failures in classic compact Mac models.
*which might be part of Stanford's Apple museum collection or at the Computer History Museum?
# Radio Shack
Model I
Model II (not compatible)
Model III (weakly compatible with Model I)
Color Computer (not compatible)
# Commodore
PET
VIC (not compatible)
64 (not compatible)
Amiga (not compatible)
# Atari
400
800 (mostly compatible)
ST (??).
# IBM
PC
PC jr (weakly compatible with Model I)
PS/2(mostly compatible)
Doing this from memory. Sure I got some this wrong but it illustrates the point that compatibility had not been show to be so important
Byte Magazine's review (https://archive.org/details/byte-magazine-1983-12/page/n287/...) described it as "daring to be somewhat different".
One reason could be the tendency to disregard the cost of software, which is a mistake people still make today.
But there was also another factor back then: computer hardware was very expensive. It is understandable to think that, if you're going to spend a gigantic pile of money on computer equipment, then it needs to be the absolute best computer equipment you can get. I think wanting to squeeze the most value out of your investment could explain why buyers and manufacturers were willing to sacrifice compatibility.
The Atari 400/800, had a sort of compatible successor in the 1200XL which wasn't compatible enough so didn't sell well. Succeeded by the 600XL * 800XL that were actually compatible. Those were followed by the 65XE/130XE/XEGS. The ST was a parallel different line.
The IBM PC jr was just IBM being idiots with their product differentiation. Notice, it didn't do well because it sucked at compatibility.
Amiga was bought.
Compatibility was actually important when it the predecessor system was popular. Some companies didn't do it well.
However, these were not the special modules used in the Apple 3, but 64kBit DRAMs which had a fault in one half of the matrix, such as TI TMS4532-20 or OKI M3732. The defective half of the chip was simply disabled.
One reference is http://www.softnology.biz/pdf/lecture05-dram.pdf
>"The second layer of polysilicon (poly 2) is arranged in diagonal regions to implement the selection transistors."
Since the diagonal polysilicon covers two different capacitors how is each one selected independently? Does each one have separate metal wire connected to it?
Is the sense line really a bunch of different sense lines? Does each bit have its own sense? Is the sense line part of the metal wiring then?
Thus, each horizontal row select line is connected to 128 different transistor gates, in other words connected to 64 of the diagonal poly 2 regions.
The confusing part is that the rows zig-zag a bit to improve the density. In other words, the physical rows in the photo don't quite match the electrical/logical rows. Look at the photo and imagine pulling it apart like a zipper. Then shift the middle part up half a step so the capacitors line up. Then the logical rows are all in a straight line. Hopefully that explanation isn't entirely confusing. In brief, the two capacitors with the same poly 2 diagonal are in the same electrical row, so they are selected together (along with 126 other capacitors).
I'll probably write more about this, so let me know if there is a clearer way to explain this :-)