> What you wrote about the virtues of newtype was explained quite well in the post itself
The post implied that the newtype-based approach was somehow "not type safety" and offered significantly less safety in practice than the constructive model approach. The first of those is definitely false, and based on my own experiences I don't believe the second.
> Further, it's important to understand what the critical additional steps are in such approaches to achieving that safety and avoid cargo-culting "newtypes make things type-safe", and to understand the ways this safety can be violated.
Naively it sounds like that would be important, but I'm not convinced it actually is in practice. My experience is that even a cargo-culty use of newtypes delivers most (maybe even all) of the defect rate benefit, and that these vigorous warnings about newtypes are more likely to reduce real-world safety (because people faced with cases that they can't produce a constructive model for will be encouraged to use an alias, or no type at all, rather than a newtype) than improve it.