Wrong why? I mean, in a time of scarcity how do you ensure that only those who need it the most are able to self-moderate their purchases?
I should point out the fact that artificially restricted selling prices lead to shortages really quick, as people tend to binge buy in those circumstances thus depleting supplies. It happens with bottled water in hurricanes, it happened with toilet paper in the first covid19 lockdowns, and it sure as hell happened with face masks as well.
Econ 101 doesn't talk much about the impact of wealth inequality on free-market mechanisms, for some reason.
As the covid19 pandemic showed, they surely are not the ones buying them all all at artificially restricted prices either, because the jackass with the shopping carts and the desperate need to hoard all types of basics decided to clean up the inventory.
> Econ 101 doesn't talk much about the impact of wealth inequality on free-market mechanisms, for some reason.
As much as it might pain you, basic economy principles are a kin to natural laws, in the sense that even if you try your hardest to pretend they don't exist... They are always there.
Additionally, one of the main errors you're making is conflating how economies work with your personal opinion on how you preferred things to happen without paying any attention to unintended consequences, let alone basic relationships between cause and effect.
killing, stealing and raping are "a kin to natural laws". They exist, but don't pretend that they're helping.
The free market would have helped if it got masks to those who need it. It didn't. It therefore, in this context, failed to help, natural laws or no. All else is philosophy.
On the other hand, how do you ensure that the poor have equal access to items that could save their life?
Here is an interesting podcast episode about this phenomenon in an area hit by a hurricane: https://www.econtalk.org/munger-on-price-gouging/
This is also what happened in a number of European countries due to the pandemic.
This gets trotted out again and again even though it doesn't apply to the kind of price gouging we saw at the beginning of the pandemic. It wasn't 3M raising prices, it was third parties buying up supply in bulk and then reselling at a higher price. This has no impact on supply, because the manufacturer is not seeing any increase in profit margin - it's all going to parasitic rent seekers in the middle.
Don't make the mistake of ignoring physical reality when talking about economy. A market isn't just a list of prices. Behind those numbers are real goods that exchange hands and have to be produced. If you just play around with some numbers you don't change anything about reality. Government price controls such as minimum wages or maximum prices for goods are just that: Playing with numbers. Since the government absolves itself of the consequences of its policies it can promise the moon and get away with causing pain and suffering.
If you really want a solution then you should start by enacting a policy that combines both the physical and economical world and sets the right incentives. Instead of a minimum wage have a job guarantee, instead of enforcing a maximum price on private sellers have a commodity guarantee that you will sell and produce masks at a fixed price. Once you fix the physical world the economical portion will fix itself.
Direct to consumer sales are a relatively new thing. Retailers and other middlemen are still the overwhelming majority of volume for stuff like masks, toilet paper, soap. Or do you buy toilet paper online straight from the manufacturer?
Btw, in a country without significant manufacturing capacity, everyone importing the needed goods is a "parasitic rent seeker".
On the other hand, if you are talking about hospitals and other institutional buyers, from what I've seen, it was mostly US based institutions and companies outbidding everyone else. Are you saying that you would have preferred those masks, respirators or ventilators remained in China or the EU?
Are you saying that all health products should be excluded from normal market forces and that someone (government?) should mandate fixed prices on all of them at all times? That just by virtue of being health-related they should not be in the normal market? We sure don't seem to do or particularly fancy this type of economic planning anywhere in the west...
In this situation it also makes sure that the rich can be a lot better protected from a virus than the poor, that is not ethical in my mind. Yes, the market will produce more, but that takes time, time during which people die.
It isn't the rich peoples' fault, or the poor peoples', that there was a sudden surge in demand for these goods, or that the market did its job in adjusting the goods to their new real price in order to keep them on shelves. That's exactly what you want. Otherwise, no amount of luck or hard work will allow you to get that good even if you really, really, want it, and are willing to sacrifice other goods in order to pay the elevated -- but worth it, due to the circumstances -- price, because that elevated price was banned by people crying about "price gouging."
I need to get off of this website.