The ISPs and cell networks actually do the hard and expensive work of installing hardware, while FANG companies make most of the profits on the back of it.
Would you rather own shares in Google/FB/Amazon or Comcast/Verizon/ATT?
The ISPs and cell networks actually do the hard and expensive work of installing hardware, while FANG companies make most of the profits on the back of it.
Would you rather own shares in Google/FB/Amazon or Comcast/Verizon/ATT?
Comcast and Charter essentially have a [duopoly](https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/07/comca...) over much of the United States. Where is the competition? The actual competition is in lobbying local governments to make ISP-as-utility illegal. See the [case of Wilson, North Carolina](https://www.npr.org/2020/05/29/865908114/small-america-vs-bi...).
People seem to easily forget that every major corporation is evil by default. If it is profitable, it gets done. Laws and public image are the only thing holding them back.
60 to 90 percent of households have access to two or more options for fixed (wired) broadband[1] depending on how you classify broadband, and that's not even counting the wireless options.
That, to me, seems as about as competitive as you're reasonably ever going to get across a medium that is a natural monopoly without putting the government in the same line of business, which quite frankly, I don't see as their place.
[1]: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/06/50-mi...
The DSL that is my second option is garbage (slow, expensive).
Redundant connections to homes are a lot cheaper when you are talking about cable vs water or power, and the hardware required to provide ISP presence isn't particularly comparable to things like water or power plants (it's considerably cheaper).
And your DSL being too slow and expensive for your use case says nothing about the use case of someone else, or even anyone outside of your immediate market area.
That chart says 52 to 80% if you're looking at wired internet, the upper end relies on classifying "3Mbps+" as broadband, and the "or more" part of "two or more" is doing a whole lot of work when it turns out 80% of those have two options. That means 48% of US households had a single or no choice if they wanted download speeds over 25Mbps.
...and we don't actually know what the real numbers are because the FCC doesn't require household level reporting, it's census block level reporting, and it's not even if a single household in that census block has service, it's if a single household in that census block could have service "without an extraordinary commitment of resources" by the ISP.
See [1]. Spoiler: the updated maps still aren't in.
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/08/the-fccs-horribl...
I've always viewed Google, Facebook, Twitter, et. al. as very "soft" companies in terms of their competitive advantage. AT&T literally owns parts of the electromagnetic spectrum for their exclusive use. This is a completely different dimension of advantage.