Square these two sentences, because you can't accidentally "only pay lip service to the scientific method". Are you or aren't you claiming that scientists feign their rigor?
> If someone, in person, testifies to their personal experience, that it had an impact on their life, you would ignore that?
I would not ignore that. But what works for someone does not necessarily work for anyone else, or even for that same person but under different circumstances. That's why we need statistics and rigor in methods.
> If you take the word of 'science' over an individual's open expression
I do not. Contrary to what you say, both are often biased, both are often tools used to promote corporate and other agendas — especially anecdotes on social media sites (including HN!) by god-knows-who — and both are often wrong. But unlike your average anecdote-offerer, scientists test whether their results generalize at all, and take many measures to mitigate bias. Anecdotes are important, but at most, the truth they give you is "I did this and my situation improved". Actual research tends to say a lot more than that.
> And, be honest, you don't even need them to provide evidence for you to accept whatever they state.
I suggest that you stop such insinuation.