But I do believe there is a big difference between being humble, and being falsely humble.
I believe in being humble, to a point, but typically not in being falsely humble.
Being humble is generally good. Maybe you are better at maths than someone, or better at arguing logically. It is good to be humble, and to realise that even if you are smarter than someone in one dimension, they may still have plenty to teach you, and that there may still be a lot of worth to what they say. As a result, its a mistake to write off their beliefs, or to come out and perhaps tell them you are smarter 'overall'!
But I think its ethically problematic when you decide to 'one-two' other people, by deliberately downplaying your abilities.
The author is effectively saying "You know you are smarter - but you should hide that, so you can effectively manipulate others." I don't think this is a good attitude.
For one, I think it shows the very social cluelessness that the author is accusing others of.
Your human relationships should not be treated as if you were a spy behind enemy lines. If you think this is an appropriate framework with which to reason about your human relationships, you are doing something /very wrong/.
I think the attitude expressed in the blog post, is, frankly, condescending, manipulative, and very patronising to the people the author chooses to mislead.
If someone did that to me, I'd lose respect for them.
Now, I must make two things clear: While I think its good to strive for honesty in human relationships, obviously you have to take care for other peoples feelings. It is, of course, necessary, to give gentle feedback, or to sometimes leave things unsaid, for the greater good. But this should ideally be done with their interests in mind - not yours.
And sometimes - perhaps you are in a critical business context, where some one who genuinely is a moron in the ways that matter, and not a nice person, and is going to cause your company a lot of damage, unless you massage their ego - or perhaps you are, indeed, a spy; in which case it is necessary to use techniques like the authors 'one-two'.
But this should be used only when its unavoidable.
Its not a desirable state of affairs, and its not what we should aspire to in our interpersonal relationships.
If you build this culture in your startup, for example, you'll have a situation where people won't know they can trust each others opinions.
The author writes: >"Even after you know it was a lie, the false-humility still gives you warm feelings. Now when this guy later turns around and says "Aw, naw, not really; well, I guess kind of I dabble in the Ultimate Truth", I'll probably listen."
Well, I'd instantly be suspicious that whatever he was telling me about the ultimate truth, was to serve his own ends.
Be nice to people, definitely - but strive for honesty, and don't set out to manipulate.