Your conclusions from your example are factually not true, because there are schools where everyone gets a "good education" that do not have pre-selection criteria. I would also agree that not everyone is capable of "mastering each topic," but why do you need to master them and why do they need to know each topic? I'm sorry, I just don't feel like you answered my question. I don't think you need great teachers to have everyone learn material. The onus of learning should be on the student and our goals for what students should learn are maligned with this concept. The fact that there isn't a definition for bad teachers doesn't mean there aren't bad teachers (you have to agree with this) and that something shouldn't be done about them. The way that I look at the three points you have numbered is that the first one follows from the other two. By working to redefine classroom expectations to closer align with placing responsibility on students for doing the learning, we can realize that more people can effectively learn appropriate material to a satisfactory comprehension level.