Why giving poor kids computers doesn't improve scholastic performance.
slate.com
slate.com
So, no, a tool that can both provide distraction and unleash a creative mind to explore is not exactly what you'd want to hand someone you'd like to meet the above goal. Its quite likely the opposite. For God's sake, give it to them!
Whether a computer improves a student's performance on algebra or history is really not too important.
My grades were never stellar. I was just never driven to excel in school and avoided homework whenever possible. Instead of studying, I spent my time learning about computers.
All that time on the computer definitely hurt my scholastic performance, but it did wonders for my career performance.
My grades have always been good, but I think that's more because of my parents' influence. My mom is a teacher and helped me find books on subjects that weren't offered in my school, so I would be less likely to hit material that I would be learning later in class. She also encouraged me to write.
My dad introduced me to programming and Pascal in elementary school. I went to a rural public high school in Louisiana, so my dad would often pick up old college textbooks in subjects my high school didn't offer, like chemistry, Latin, and history from a non Christian perspective. He also stood up for me when my guidance counselor tried to put me on the MRS. track instead of college. If I had to sit through 4 years of home ec and parenting classes, I would have dropped out as soon as I turned 16.
I think kids tend to do better in school when their parents care. An involved parent could use a computer to enhance their child's education. A non involved parent might use it as "tv 2.0" - just another thing to entertain their kid so they don't have to.
Because, fundamentally, the curricula is solid - Math doesn't change that often, Physics/Chemistry/Biology/Earth Sciences are well established fields. History is ongoing, but given what High School history classes focus on, it's not going to change much. English/Literature isn't going to change an incredible amount - new books can be added in, but Shakespeare's words haven't changed since he wrote them. Writing styles may come and go, but thats just a small part of everything learned in HS.
It depends what you mean by computer skills. E.g. everything needs to read and write - only a few specialists need to know how to make paper and bind books, and they learn that as adults.
My schools always had computers, and I never observed anything to suggest they aided in teaching. At best, they were labor-saving: More efficient than typewriters, more efficient than paper indices, more efficient than microfiche, etc.