Why not?
With the same reasoning you could deny selling people food unless they show you their government ID.
Would you consider such an abomination a country where privacy still exists?
If you strip people from basic anonymity for no sane reason they have no privacy.
If all you want is to prevent people from signing up infinite accounts then have them solve a bazillion captchas or pay a token amount of cryptocurrency, but don't ask them to connect their account to completely unrelated private information.
Email operates independently of cell phone numbers, so it shouldn't be required to connect yours to your mail address.