Source of data is Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests for change of address stats from USPS.
EDIT: Y'all shouldn't use this single data point alone for anything of value.
The plural of anecdote is not data, but for what it's worth I personally know of more people in the second bucket than the first. Time will tell, of course.
I'm in NYC 3-5 times a month. It's slower with fewer office workers in Manhattan, but it's still NYC. Manhattan is less busy in some areas anyway as the new construction of money laundering condo units get built. Queens, Brooklyn, etc look pretty much the same, but then the scope of "everyone" fleeing to their Hamptons beach homes is limited in scope.
Anecdote: my parents live in an outer suburb of NYC, about an hour driving with zero traffic, that has a train line to Hoboken (with a couple options to transfer to NYC, or just take a ferry from hoboken) that takes like 90 minutes one-way. They've actually seen a ton of people move into the developments around them this year.
People want the space, the lower cost, and it's a pretty area near hiking trails and nice parks. Schools aren't top-tier but they're pretty good.
Sure, nobody wants a 90 minute+ train ride every day, but if you only have to do it a couple times a week, and there are tech jobs in NJ itself to eventually seek out, it's not a bad choice.