MPs demand Amazon explain why Alexa offers antisemitic messages and conspiracies
news.sky.com
news.sky.com
How do we solve this? Do we have to create a blacklist of sources we want to avoid indexing? How do we prevent innocent articles from being truncated before the vital "however these are all baseless rumours"?
If you're going to design a search engine that responds to factual queries with a single statement, it's reasonable to expect those statements to be true.
Because Google manipulates the results.
At least my intuition is that getting information from these intentionally friendly sounding voice assistants might even be more convincing for people than getting a list of search results on a webpage. I wonder if there's any studies on this.
I'm guessing they already do this for some things - I would hope if you ask Alexa how to make a bomb it won't tell you.
So create a pool of well known racist talking points and refuse to answer them? That does sound plausible.
A more general "racism detector" would be rather non-trivial to write.
- Why don't vaccinations work?
- Was the moon landing faked?
- Are there differences in IQ between countries?
You have to ask what we are trying to solve here. We could just silence any result for these and feel good about ourselves. We've removed offensive elements from Alexa.
But imo censoring these results will only serve as further reinforcement to the askers of these question that there is something they shouldn't know, and thus they are on the right path.
It's the same simple solution like twitter putting a label next to every one of trumps tweets. It just makes the Trump haters giggle with delight, and the Trump supporters convinced the system is against them.
> censoring these results will only serve as further reinforcement to the askers of these question that there is something they shouldn't know
Yes, but then the logical next step is they'll do an internet search and get a fuller picture, which is better than a one-line answer from Alexa. Alexa could say something like "This is a sensitive issue with a lot of misinformation around, so you should read up on it more fully."
I guess my fear is that when you open this door to filtering/censorship, at one point a true unfiltered web search may no longer exist.
How rational can you expect a decision to be when the information that went into making it is lies?
It would be nice if for major topics (ex. COVID) there was some authoritative source that the voice assistants used, but that wouldn't solve the entire problem since there are pretty much infinite search queries that will return some kind of conspiracy as the top result.
This sounds like an excuse for a group of Tory cronies to hide the fact they were spouting anti-Semitism into an Alexa as a laugh.
Chances are Tory MPs have a closer to ear to the Jewish communities given how that conflict from abroad tragically maps into our political system. So its likely someone in those communities heard of it and wrote to an MP about it.
My (((own))) family in the UK are all habitual Labour voters. In the last election, so far as I know, they mostly swung Tory because that nice Mr Corbyn frightened them. Not going to argue if they should have been worried about him or not. The simple fact is that they were. So far as I know from conversations with them, they all plan to vote for Labour again at the next election. From this, it has been my assumption that there is plenty of support for Labour in the Jewish community in the UK, Israel/Palestine notwithstanding. Perhaps it is the case that many people really can tell the difference between criticism of Israel, and picking on Israel to the exclusion of all else, and think they saw one thing in the Labour Party before Corbyn, and another during, and yet another after. Of course, we're back to my assumptions again. YMMV.
Thus is the curse of the FPTP system.
And those three hardly ever agree on anything, so this clearly cuts across party lines.