Permissions (and ownership info) can be useful even if you have complete access to a filesystem.
By the way, assume you have root permission. How would you replace a single file in a random tar-file, without changing any of the permissions/userids/groupids inside the tar-file? You can't untar it because the users inside the tar file don't correspond with the ones on your system. So, you'll have to use special tools, which is (only) one demonstration of the inadequacy of the permissions mechanism of our filesystems.