Somewhere along the way, this part of Apple culture got lost. I think Apple's commercial success is part of the reason. The traditional Mac user base got diluted by lots of newcomers who didn't have the same high expectations and requirements for good and consistent user interfaces. The traditional Mac developers got diluted by programmers from other platforms, who – although not being technically inferior in any way – did not have the same passion or understanding of Apple's UI philosophy, often not even bothering to study the Human Interface Guidelines.
Funny thing is that those are both products that many are reaching for alternatives to whenever viable. As powerful as they may be as tools, there's quite a lot that's throughly mediocre or even bad about them.
There are examples of truly great apps that use their own look and feel, but I don't think either of those are among them.