In the west, individuals are much more autonomous and that enables more effective social associations where people are gathering in groups based on their levels of competence, interests and views.
In the west, individuals are much more autonomous and that enables more effective social associations where people are gathering in groups based on their levels of competence, interests and views.
Western liberalism and individual freedom is really a very recent development. Just 100 years ago, people were being forced to work on ships, in factories, on farms, in wars and 3-4 generations living in one home was normal. Just 60 years ago, many people were heavily discriminated against and had little freedom.
Imo, these "more effective social associations" just lead to an increase in mental problems and perhaps ultimately, to the unraveling of such societies. Long term *ships are good, the focus on hyper efficiency just means more and more people are being left behind, and groups simply have no idea what other groups are thinking or how to work with them.
See all the antimaskers, antivaxxers, authoritarian supporters. All dismissed as stupid/irrelevant and considered a minority by the other side. And vice versa. The reality is different, but there's such a disconnect that no one knows how to fix this.
You know those jobs are still necessary, right? Still exist? People are just as forced into them now as they were in 1920 especially outside the developed world. You're complaining that life in antiquity was hard and attributing it to a failure of society.
What if it's just the nature of reality that life is hard, brutish, and short, and the slice of modernity we've enjoyed briefly for the last half century has been a reprieve offered by liberalism?
Also how do you even bundle anti maskers and authoritarians in one sentence? Anti maskers aren't telling people not to go to church or visit their families, or to die alone. The authoritarians are on the other side, like Mr Andrew Cuomo. He's the one literally persecuting Jews in New York for practicing their beliefs in a way that is politically unfashionable due to a disease with a 99.9% survival rate.
You might disagree with them but anti maskers are anti authoritarian. They are literally fighting authority.
Lots of people have sacrificed their lives to give us a better one. I'm only from an ex-USSR country, and I've never been to countries worse off, but from what I read, workers rights have taken hold pretty much everywhere.
The anti-maskers/pro-authoritarians part was in reply to "people are gathering in groups based on their levels of competence, interests and views".
Yes, everyone gathers in their own groups with narrow views, and they don't have to live or even communicate with people who have different views. So they don't even try to understand the opposing point of view. It's automatically just them "being dumb", "just wrong" or "fake news" or whatever.
It might make for more effective social associations in the short term, but I don't see how it's sustainable in the long term. It's the same exact type of divide that exists between the wealthy and the rest.
Post-WW2, the working class was largely replaced by a well-off middle class, and that created other problems in itself.
Indeed, we do owe our modern lives to the privileged people who nonetheless chose to fight for the commoner, raising everyone's living standards.
"most other contemporary non-Western societies?" You are a rare anthropologist to make this assertion. Both endogamy and exogamy are common across the globe, and have been for millennia.
I think this book excerpt overstates the case.
[0] Woodley, Michael A.; Edward Bell (2013). "Consanguinity as a Major Predictor of Levels of Democracy: A Study of 70 Nations". Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology. 44 (2): 263–280. doi:10.1177/0022022112443855. S2CID 145714074.
[1] Degrees are counted by how many nodes in the tree have to be traversed upward to reach the nearest common direct ancestor. For example siblings are second degree since the two siblings share a common ancestor. An uncle and nephew would be 3rd degree, first cousins 4th degree, and so on.
* https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/inbreeding-and...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cousin_marriage_in_the_Middle_...
This must have some serious negative effect on the societies there, especially when done for 50 consecutive generations.
https://www.muslimcouncilofamerica.org/cousin-marriage-among...
"Roman civil law prohibited marriages within four degrees of consanguinity[44] but had no degrees of affinity with regards to marriage."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incest#Antiquity (Top of third to last paragraph in section)