I'm not sure it even counts as a study, where was it published? Is there a preprint somewhere? Is it just a PowerPoint presentation?
I'm not sure it even counts as a study, where was it published? Is there a preprint somewhere? Is it just a PowerPoint presentation?
Just how valuable is it to be a credible person, especially if you want to make an impact in the world, such as by being a doctor or researcher?
It's not an ad hominem to try to deflate an appeal to authority by pointing out that the authority is not all it's cracked up to be, and that the extent of the supposed study is some charts.
Additionally, the Applied Economics master’s degree program is an adult extension program located on a satellite campus. Its student admission requirements [1] are substantially less rigorous than a traditional master's program at one of JHU's main schools.
I agree the headline here is completely misleading, as it attempts to tie the content to other schools/divisions of JHU that have a much more solid academic reputation.
[1] https://advanced.jhu.edu/academics/graduate/ms-applied-econo...
That is what any serious institution would do.
I have previously poked around NYC-area death statistics and it looks like 1) a massive spike in deaths by any cause that looks like several 9/11s followed by 2) a regression to the usual rate of deaths once COVID was largely brought to heel in the summer months. I can't imagine that the total number of deaths in NYC this year could possibly be the same as in 2019.
But I'm not an expert.
Ed: glancing over the CDC statistics, when COVID-attributed deaths go up, all-cause mortality goes up, too... by approximately the same amount. If a large proportion of those COVID deaths were mislabeled heart disease deaths, why is that? I made these graphs with the same CDC data:
And of course, there's the CDC's own dashboard on excess deaths, which lets you slice this more finely.
https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm
The charts "Weekly number of deaths (from all causes)" shows it's a big deal.
Or, select the dashboard "Excess deaths with and without COVID-19" and see that the number of deaths without COVID is pretty close to the expected number of deaths, and not a drop that would compensate for the COVID deaths.
You can also see that while the linked-to site claims "The CDC classified all deaths that are related to COVID-19 simply as COVID-19 deaths.", the CDC writes:
> For example, in some cases, COVID-19 may have contributed to the death, but the underlying cause of death was another cause, such as terminal cancer. For the majority of deaths where COVID-19 is reported on the death certificate (approximately 95%), COVID-19 is selected as the underlying cause of death.
Furthermore, the CDC write "deaths from all causes excluding COVID-19 were also estimated. Comparing these two sets of estimates — excess deaths with and without COVID-19 — can provide insight about how many excess deaths are identified as due to COVID-19, and how many excess deaths are reported as due to other causes of death."
Since the surface-level description contradicts easily available evidence, why do you believe the rest of the details are any more meaningful?