What we know about Earth’s new minimoon
universetoday.com
universetoday.com
This object is 1 to 2 meters in diameter, was captured by Earth for just 2.7 years, and with an extremely irregular orbit.
By contrast, a moon requires a "relatively stable orbit" [1], which this clearly did not have.
Can we just call it what it actually is? It's an asteroid. It revolves around the Sun, and it was very briefly a temporary satellite of the Earth.
Smells clickbait :-/
If we know its trajectory with decent precision when it left, and we know the position and gravitational strength of the earth, moon and sun, and you just plug in the numbers and simulate and it should be quite straightforward.
I suppose you're referring to "chaotic" meaning that tiny variations or mismeasurements in its later trajectory would be vastly amplified as its orbits were traced. But my understanding is that such chaotic/unpredictable orbital effects generally show up on the scale of many many thousands of orbits if not much more, not 2 years?
And remember that while the low spatial and temporal resolution of the GIF makes it seem like just being a "pixel" off could result in a totally different orbit (like chaos theory)...
...the actual simulation is dealing with distances of hundreds of thousands of miles, simulated over multiple years of time, presumably with something like minute-by-minute, meter-by-meter precision. (Remember, the object itself is only 1-2 meters large.)
The "unintuitive right angle" would appear entirely intuitive if you actually watched it slower while zoomed in closer to the moon.
* Lots of space junk is very small (e.g. paint flecks and metal chips) and we don’t know exactly where it is (but even objects of this small size can still be hazardous travelling at 5km/s).
* When we do know where it is, it’s probably still uneconomic to spend delta-V getting to it and pushing it anywhere.
* Potentially unknown payloads on old satellites, or uncertain ownership status. Russia might have opinions on someone else touching its junk.
* Proliferation risk of developing technology that can easily interfere with satellites on-demand. If a satellite mover can move junk, it can move live units too.
* Actual risk of error causing uncontrolled deorbiting, either with a mis-push, or by bouncing junk off the growing moon-like mass
* That moon-like mass could easily become a liability - irregularly shaped with hard-to-model behaviour. Most space junk will burn up on reentry, but a giant agglomeration of metal might survive reentry and land on something it shouldn’t.
Do we need to spend delta-V? We can use a friggin' laser, or a giant magnet, or or or. Typically, we'd just need to slow it down so that it just re-enters the atmosphere.
* Proliferation risk of developing technology that can easily interfere with satellites on-demand. If a satellite mover can move junk, it can move live units too.
Like anything else, actions have consequences. To be able to make something like this, they'd have to be a pretty decent player in the space realm. If all of the other players quit playing with you because you break all of the rules, the game gets lonely.
if you randomly choose 20 dead satellites by their TLEs, they're all in different inclinations and orbits. plane change manoeuvres are very costly in delta-v.
there is no economic incentive or need to build a lot of individual dead-satellite-grabbing ion/hall effect thruster powered satellites that would go up and grab things to shove them into a katamari-damacy like ball of dead satellites.
It mostly worked fine & 30 odd discarded cores are orbiting the Earth in a safe graveyard orbit. Just a few fell back.
A lot of time, energy and money is spent getting material into orbit. No sense wasting it, unless it's completely useless. Then de-orbiting in the Earth's atmosphere is the cheapest solution.
I haven't done the napkin math but maybe I'm sorely mistaken in terms of the physics involved. Could be interesting to lower the cost by pushing into a huge mass and then once it was too large pushing that mass into the sun?
ʻOumuamua would have been a long shot but this rock seems within reach.
So unlike a cosy stable state vacuum of space with sun in one direction to point the solar panels and Earth in another where you point the antennas, you are now sitting an a pice of material that can freeze you/cook you by convection & Sun an Earth continually change position.
Also unlike with a space probe that can have a hot (in the sun) and cold (in the shadow) sides, now you need to handle temperature management from multiple constantly changing angles. Fun!
Thats why we don't regularly communicate with NEAR Shoemaker or Rosetta even though both landed on a space rock - they are simply no longer in a working order.
That doesn't mean it's impossible - you just need to use a rather more complicated spacecraft for that, than just trying to land a space probe.