(Not affiliated with the project in any way, just watching closely out of professional interest).
(Not affiliated with the project in any way, just watching closely out of professional interest).
That is simply false. Maybe known to insiders at eFabless.
Seriously where do you see any public mention of "caravel" three months ago? There's absolutely nothing about it on the mailing lists [1] [2].
> it was announced at the start of the program
Where?
I heard about this in late July and have been following this very closely since they posted the design rules in early September. I've probably read through the DRC rule document more closely than anybody outside of Google/Skywater/eFabless. Two weeks ago there was nothing anywhere in any of that about having to use their "Caravel" management padframe.
As of 15-Sep (git commit 107103f922db43408f59a1540cd4bd3737b30172) the text "caravel" does not appear anywhere in the PDK [3]. I checked with:
$ find . -not -type d -exec grep -Hi caravel {} \;
This was sprung on us two weeks before the deadline. Not cool. A lot of karma and goodwill burned.[1] https://groups.google.com/d/forum/skywater-pdk-announce
Really? Where can we read about it?
> E.g. see https://youtu.be/EczW2IWdnOM from June around the one hour mark.
What are you referring to, where exactly in there? I poked "around the one hour mark" and didn't stumble across it, but am not gonna watch the whole thing. It's over an hour of somebody talking at a camera.
Does an offhand comment buried in the middle of a 90-minute youtube ramble really strike you as appropriate notification of such an important requirement? Especially when this requirement doesn't appear anyplace where it can be read?
In other words, the video says you can simply not connect to it and not use it if you don't want it. He never says anything about it being hardwired to the padframe.
Then, two weeks before tapeout, they changed the rules and made this thing not only mandatory, but made it the only way your design can boot up or communicate with the outside world.
This was a bait and switch.
I didn't get that impression. As I understood it, the probing and controlling is, entirely, "if you want". However IO via the harness is not optional. As the other user says, perhaps this was not communicated clearly to you, but an intentional bait and switch it doesn't appear to be.
There's some discussion of the harness on skywater-pdk-users, and it was mentioned in various comments in the previous discussion on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23755693