Truck driving jobs aren't going anywhere, not in 10 years, not in a 100 . Neither is that of plumbers, electricians or many such skilled labors. Most programmers will lose their jobs before any of that happens.
Truck driving jobs aren't going anywhere, not in 10 years, not in a 100 . Neither is that of plumbers, electricians or many such skilled labors. Most programmers will lose their jobs before any of that happens.
The other thing to keep in mind, is that we automate tasks not jobs. The effect of this is that workers become much more productive, it is possible to do the same work with fewer people. One truck driver oversees a fleet of trucks remotely, ready to take over if needed. The good news is that these should be higher paying jobs than the original, because they are more productive and higher skilled.
Self driving cars as a concept could in theory be killed entirely by a few high profile crashes and a few successful prosecutions for criminal negligence.
Im skeptical that the US legal/political system would kill it, though. The original automobiles were rendered "safe" by criminalizing jaywalking after all.
Take the snarkiness back to reddit please.
The problem is that trucks are one of the things that needs to be right essentially every time. If a truck is right 99.9% of the time it is doing considerably worse from a financial liability standpoint than a truck driver.
One truck accident of any severity will incur liability expenses in the millions and often tens of millions of dollars. And with automated trucks there are no owner operators to externalize that liability to.
Outsourcing truck driving via tele-driving on the other hand, seems incredibly likely if regulatory questions can be answered.
Go back five years and these trucks would have be driven by a human driver.
Today any new mine will be designed to use autonomous trucks and many of the older mines are being retro fitted to replace those human driven trucks:
https://www.amsj.com.au/autonomous-mining-truck-safety/
Now replacing drivers for trucks driven on public roads is much harder to achieve, but even here systems that reduce the number of drivers required are well advanced:
https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/industry/daimler-trials-c...
Same will happen to trucks and trains. You may see some sort of fully automated cars in some small cities in the next couple of decades. But trucks? Nope! Not happening.
Short-haul/local drivers however yes, they will continue to exist for now due to the additional complexity preseneted by everyone and their mom's loading dock being all kinds of differently designed, often in ridiculous ways.
Of course they're lining for it, but if no one delivers L5 autonomy trucks, then they'll still be stuck with drivers.
I have yet to see any evidence of a self driving vehicle that can handle anything other than the simple roads of sunny AZ or CA.
Show me one that can handle a snow squall or heavy rain or missing signs and lane markers and construction zones, and I might think it’s possible this decade.
Otherwise, I assume there’s a lot of work to be done.
https://venturebeat.com/2019/04/26/5-companies-are-testing-5...
(Maybe they’ll finally figure out the belt system /s)
Since they don’t advertise being able to drive in less than ideal weather, I assume it means they can’t yet.
I’m not disagreeing about weather constraints in the ODD. But I don’t think anyone who’s driven in Pittsburgh thinks it has “simple roads” like Chandler, AZ. I should have been more explicit I was only responding to that aspect.
If anything, I think truck drivers’ jobs will be resilient and in demand with all the move to delivery in the next decade or even two.
It’s going to take a lot of time and data to prove the safety of self driving trucks and sort out the calculation of liability and who is insuring what.
Look, they're just machines, they're not miracle workers ;-)
We built the railroads because it paid. It's not about where we are, but where we'll be going.
And the next step would be correct recognition and behaviour based on the current location. Different countries use different colors and styles for road markings. Some use yellow lines in the middle, others orange in the case of redirection around construction sites. Then there are the cases where the lines are simply incorrect or out of date(which famously lead to the fatal Tesla autopilot crash).
It is impressive how far the technology has come, but it's an area with countless edge cases and unpredictable situations coupled with high stakes if something goes wrong. I can see self-driving trucks being adopted slowly on specific routes, but a full switch not labeled as "pilot project" will still take a while I think.
I don't think one would just plop a general system on any route without human-supervised customization -- at least we're not there yet.
The first cheat is to only automate the long-haul portion. As anybody who has driven cross country knows, long stretches of American highway barely require you to be conscious, let alone skilled. The truck pulls over before needs to get on city streets and a human driver gets in.
The second cheat is what Waymo is doing. If the car doesn't know what to do, it slows or stops and asks for help from a central driver that plots a path through the hard part for it. This works for trucking because network coverage on highways is very good.
The third cheat is to work around the limitations. If the weather is going to be bad, the truck waits or takes an alternate route. If it gets into trouble like a freak snowstorm, it either proceeds very slowly or just stops until either conditions improve or a human driver can get to it.
This approach isn't perfect automation, but it will significantly drop labor cost right away, and it gives you a lot of road-miles to iteratively chip away at the problems.
Highways have decent network coverage but nothing close to the levels of reliability necessary to satisfy the actuaries. From a risk perspective, failure mitigation strategies like slowing or stopping are largely hamstrung by the same reliability concerns that prevent the vehicle from simply driving on its own, the vehicle may simply not recognize that the situation is dangerous until it's too late, that's without factoring in the reality that stopping or slowing can actually be extremely dangerous and can't be relied upon as a catch-all fallback. Additionally, I think you're greatly underestimating the practical problems involved in operating a remote emergency-on-call driver system, there's also some questionable economics around the idea of paying to keep someone on call when you could just pay them to drive the truck.
On top of all that there are various other hard problems that need solving like fueling and security. You can be sure that automated trucks hauling valuable cargo will find themselves regularly waylaid by sophisticated criminals who will be greatly encouraged by the lack of a human element to resist their efforts. Truck drivers don't really get paid that much money, the risks just aren't worth it.
Network coverage? On most big interstates it's perfectly fine, even through mountain ranges, and it's known in advance which highways don't have it. But even then, you can just use satellite systems such as Starlink as a backup.
Questionable economics for keeping people on-call? No, it's quite economic, because one on-call person can provide coverage for a wide area.
Criminals? This is an unserious idea that's always brought up in these discussions. Why not break into containers at ports? Why not break into dry vans stored at the back of warehouses overnight? If the idea is just that criminals will break into unattended cargo vans, there are manifold opportunities to do this already, and the small amounts of property crime isn't a serious issue.
Anyway, it's covered by insurance.
Conversely, the advantages are numerous: * Much faster cross-country freight. No sleeping, no work-rules, no need for team drivers. * A safety profile that may even be better (no falling asleep). * Lower costs. * Better availability. At times, it is very difficult to schedule a truck to arrive, depending on how tight the market is. It's easier to flex equipment availability up and down than truckers.
Many large shippers will see this as an important area to focus on and money is being poured into this today.
The remote on-call strategy doesn't scale, yes it'll save some money relative to drivers, but there's a delicate balancing act involved in mitigating risk of multiple simultaneous failures, yes this might be rare, but it'll also be costly.
See my response to wpietri for more about security, but with respect to warehouses and the like, they are frequently staffed by armed guards or dogs, it's also orders of magnitude easier to secure a stationary facility compared to a mobile autonomous vehicle traveling across the country. Insurance will only cover it if they can tolerate the risk.
Increased availability is definitely a win, but the other advantages you listed are just alternative ways of saying "lower cost". Yes, the costs are lower, but truck driver salaries aren't that high to begin with and the cost of building out and maintaining automated trucking infrastructure will be passed on to any trucking companies that decide to adopt the technology.
I think the economics of remote backup drivers is working for Waymo, so I don't see why it wouldn't work for truck drivers, which are higher value. And for the you-need-somebody-on-site problems, there's already a network of tow and repair services that will surely be willing to send someone out.
Fueling seems similarly surmountable. Semis have very long ranges, and fuel up at specialist facilities that are just off the highway. I don't think it will take much persuasion for truck stops to offer full service fueling on a $500 fill-up. And it's not obvious that security will be worse. An automated truck is going to have a lot of high-quality cameras and be in continuous contact with a staffed operations center. The vehicle may be effectively impossible to steal, and transferring a semi's worth of cargo is not a fast process.
I think it's also important to note that to start it doesn't actually have to be better. It just has to be a) within shouting distance, and b) exciting enough that some exec thinks they'll get a promotion out of it.
[1] e.g. this from 1973 https://genius.com/Jim-croce-speedball-tucker-lyrics and this from the Trucking Alliance: https://truckingalliance.org/new-study-supports-projection-o...
The fueling concerns are pretty trivial from an engineering perspective, the problem is one of infrastructure. Yes, industry could prop up some fueling stations, but nothing approaching the coverage necessary to make it more practical than e.g freight by rail.
Security concerns are very real, there is no such thing as "impossible to steal" and the threat of cameras are trivially defeated by way of masks under cover of darkness. Transferring a semi's worth of cargo is only slow if you're not prepared to do it in advance. I also want to reemphasize the shift in psychology associated with removing the human element, criminals are absolutely going to be emboldened by the fact they are dealing with a harmless predictable computer and not a human person that might resist their efforts, cause them injury, or otherwise complicate the risk involved. It's also well known in criminal psychology that people are much more willing to justify criminal behavior they perceive as victimless.
Setting aside my practical objections, yes, it's true that it doesn't have to be better to start, but I think there's no chance it gains momentum since there is a lot of up-front cost and complexity for relatively small financial gain vs just e.g. freight by rail.
Fueling stations already exist. The only "infrastructure" needed is an agreement with a couple truck stop chains than when a robot truck pulls in, somebody goes out fill it up. Full-service gas stations are not a radical innovation.
I think your security concerns are a fairy tale. I especially suspect you have never loaded or unloaded a semi. A mask might keep a person's face from being seen, but it can't keep the theft from being detected. Trucks generally drive on well-policed, limited-access roads. For this to work, time of trouble to time of police response has to be larger than the time to break into, unload, and load a semi's worth of goods. By the side of the road. At night. Plus you need more time to get a semi, which is not an inconspicuous, far enough away from the scene of the crime, that the cops won't find it.
Will people try it? Sure. But I don't see any reason to think it becomes a major issue. Certainly not a dealbreaker, because if I'm wrong and there's a crime wave like this, a bunch of well-funded, powerful groups will be immediately demanding better police response and new laws.
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-northamptonshire-5497278...
Why anyone thinks companies would do anything more then keep an eye on their insurance rates, I don't know.
We can solve self driving, but it requires better maintained infrastructure, you can’t have self driving trucks which break down due to pot holes and black ice and no internet access clogging up the logistical supply chain.
On other hand I do agree that skilled labour jobs in maintenance and renovation jobs aren't going very soon.
Then again in new buildings automating these jobs with good design or even pre-build components is not impossible eventually.
But self-driving trucks, especially long-haul ones that drive mostly on motorways between warehouses are likely near the top of the list of replacement by self-driving vehicles.
Provided you're not actually talking about poor people just dying off in large numbers, we'll still have roughly the same number of households, which means the same number of sinks to unclog and outlets to wire. I suppose it might be true that fewer people will be able to afford the services of skilled professionals, but that's not at all the same as saying that fewer will be needed...
> TuSimple is hardly the only company working to making fully automated shipping a reality. Several companies, including Aurora, Daimler, and Embark Trucks, are competing for a slice of the future of self-driving freight trucks. Alphabet-owned Waymo confirmed on Tuesday that it will be expanding its own self-driving trucking routes throughout the American Southwest and Texas, following previous tests in Arizona, California, Michigan, and Georgia
Automation in that regard is probably a later iteration of the automated household where now we have auxillary vacuums, embedded iot light controllers, and so forth.