Yeah it seems foolhardy to threaten to leave if you're not ready to leave. That's the issue with playing hardball - you may get smacked in the face with the ball.
Yeah it seems foolhardy to threaten to leave if you're not ready to leave. That's the issue with playing hardball - you may get smacked in the face with the ball.
On the other hand, as an employer firing people this way is not very smart either. This brings a lot of attention and seems very vindictive.
Especially given the context, this reeks of fire her before she collects proof of <<insert whatever immoral thing google is doing now>> to me.
What's the point in keeping someone that disgruntled around? They can only make things worse.
Also important to the discussion is that her managers (and thus Google) appear to be framing this as "accepting her resignation" as opposed to firing her (tying into GP's point) which likely has consequences with regard to separation benefits and lets Google frame this as not being their decision (or at least would be if it weren't for Twitter/articles like this).
It seems like Gebru did things correctly with regard to reporting her unhappiness to her management team but made the mistake of mentioning possible resignation in response to a lack of change which Google jumped on as a method to protect themselves by immediately removing a possibly disgruntled employee in a way that allows them to avoid the downsides of firing her (that simple description alone not meant to imply any judgment).
Its a rather murky situation to untangle though when combined with Google's firing of employees participating in organization and other events over the last few years giving the general impression of Google "becoming evil" I does seem like the bad PR this will cause means Google's handling of the situation was a bad choice.