So like, the government says facebook had a bunch of PERM positions that they sandbagged recruiting for to Americans. But then, > while comparable positions at Facebook that were advertised on its careers website during a similar time period typically attracted 100 or more applicants each.
Are these...the same positions? How does facebook's hiring process work? Is there actually any discrete limit to the 'slots' on the careers website? Do they have 2500 listings for software engineers, or just like, everyone applies, we are looking to hire ~2000 people this year.
I can see where the government is probably right in saying "you did it wrong". But if you are facebook, and the hiring strategy is honestly:
* Hiring for the 'American' positions is only limited by the company finding the applicant skilled enough. There is no numerical cap.
* Only foreign applicants apply to a discrete, government-limited pool of PERM positions. This way you don't waste the PERM positions on Americans, who can apply to you nigh-unlimited pool of 'American' positions.
* Starting salary for everyone is the same ($156k)
I could certainly see that the government's way of interpreting your 'insidious hiring program' is flat-footed to the point of being wrong.